Amazed

Chapter 5: The Agreement That Cost My Mother Everything

Gabriel didn't open the envelope immediately.

He stared at it as though the paper itself could hurt him.

Laura Mitchell stepped inside and closed the apartment door.

"I know I should have come forward years ago," she said.

Gabriel placed the envelope on the table.

"Then start talking.""

Laura looked at me.

"Are you Emily?""

"Yes.""

She nodded.

"You look like your mother.""

I studied her face.

"Did you know her?""

"Yes. I met Sarah several times.""

"Then why didn't you help her?""

Laura lowered her eyes.

"Because I was afraid of losing my job. And because Richard Bennett made it clear that anyone who helped her would regret it.""

Gabriel's jaw tightened.

"My father is dead. You don't have to protect him anymore.""

Laura took a breath.

"Your father didn't just arrange for Sarah to disappear from your life. He arranged for the hospital records to be changed.""

I felt the room tilt.

"Changed how?""

Laura opened the envelope.

Inside was a typed agreement, several bank statements, and a document bearing the letterhead of St. Mary's Hospital.

Gabriel pulled out the first page.

It was dated November 12, 2003.

Six days after my birth.

The agreement stated that Sarah Carter would receive financial assistance in exchange for relinquishing all claims against the Bennett family.

But the most disturbing paragraph appeared near the bottom.

It said that Sarah would not be permitted to disclose the existence of a child born to Gabriel Bennett.

I read it twice.

"They wanted my mother to pretend I didn't exist?""

Laura nodded.

"Your grandfather believed a child born outside a marriage would damage the family's reputation.""

Gabriel slammed the paper onto the table.

"That doesn't explain the hospital.""

Laura looked at him.

"Your father had another concern.""

"What?""

She hesitated.

"Your marriage.""

Gabriel frowned.

"What does Vivian have to do with this?""

Laura pulled out another document.

It was a photocopy of a financial agreement between Richard Bennett and Vivian Hale, dated three months before their wedding.

I leaned closer.

The agreement contained several conditions.

One stated that Vivian would receive a substantial financial settlement if she married Gabriel and remained married to him for at least five years.

Another stated that she would have authority over certain family assets if Gabriel became incapacitated or died.

Gabriel looked sick.

"Why would she agree to this?""

Laura swallowed.

"Because she was already pregnant.""

The room went silent.

Gabriel stared at her.

"Madeline?""

Laura nodded.

"Your father knew Vivian was pregnant before the wedding. He believed the Bennett family needed an heir. He wanted the child raised inside the family, with no public scandal.""

I looked at the photograph of Madeline.

"Then why did my mother know her?""

Laura took another document from the envelope.

"Because Sarah was working at the hospital where Madeline was born.""

Gabriel looked up sharply.

"Sarah was a nurse.""

"Yes. She had taken a temporary position in the maternity ward.""

I felt my throat tighten.

Laura continued.

"Madeline was born prematurely. Vivian had complications after delivery. Sarah was one of the nurses assigned to her room.""

Gabriel slowly sat down.

"You're saying Sarah cared for my daughter?""

Laura nodded.

"She did more than that.""

She pulled out a smaller photograph.

It showed Sarah holding a baby wrapped in a yellow blanket.

The same blanket from the photograph I had brought to the restaurant.

I recognized the hospital bracelet on the baby's wrist.

Madeline Bennett.

My mother had held both of Gabriel's daughters.

One by birth.

One by circumstance.

And she'd been forced to watch them grow up without knowing each other.

I felt tears running down my face.

"Why would she keep this secret?""

Laura looked at me.

"Because Richard threatened to have you taken away.""

Gabriel stood.

"He couldn't do that.""

"He had influence. He had money. He had lawyers. Sarah was alone, and she knew it.""

Gabriel looked down at the agreement.

"Did Vivian know?""

Laura hesitated.

"She knew enough.""

I remembered Vivian's face at the restaurant.

The anger.

The panic.

The way she'd tried to take the photograph.

I asked the question that had been bothering me.

"Why did Vivian slap me?""

Laura looked directly at me.

"Because she recognized the photograph.""

Gabriel turned toward her.

"What?""

"She had seen it before. Richard kept a copy in his private office. He told Vivian that if Sarah's daughter ever appeared, she was to make sure Gabriel never learned the truth.""

Gabriel's face darkened.

"And Vivian followed those instructions?""

Laura nodded.

"She was afraid.""

"Of what?""

Laura took a long breath.

"Of losing everything.""

She placed one final document on the table.

It was a letter from Richard Bennett, written shortly before his death.

The first paragraph was addressed to Vivian.

The second was addressed to Gabriel.

But the last paragraph had my name.

To Emily Carter, if you are ever reading this, there is something your mother never told you.

I looked at Laura.

"What?""

She turned the page.

"Sarah didn't just discover the truth about your birth.""

Gabriel leaned forward.

"What else did she discover?""

Laura's voice dropped.

"She discovered that Vivian wasn't Madeline's biological mother.""

Nobody moved.

Gabriel stared at her.

"That's impossible. Vivian gave birth to Madeline.""

Laura shook her head.

"She carried her. But the egg wasn't hers.""

My heart began pounding.

Gabriel looked at the photograph of Madeline.

"Whose was it?""

Laura closed her eyes.

Then she answered.

"Sarah Carter's.""

The apartment seemed to lose all its air.

I stared at the woman standing in front of us.

"My mother?""

Laura nodded.

"Sarah donated an egg through an anonymous fertility program before she became pregnant with you. Richard arranged the procedure without telling her that the recipient was Vivian.""

Gabriel looked devastated.

"Why would my father do that?""

Laura pulled out the final page.

"Because he wanted a Bennett heir, and he knew Vivian couldn't have a biological child.""

I looked at the photograph again.

My mother had given birth to me.

And, without knowing it, she had also given life to the girl who had been raised as Gabriel's daughter.

Gabriel sank into the chair.

"Madeline is Sarah's daughter too.""

Laura nodded.

"Yes.""

I wiped my tears.

"Does Madeline know?""

Laura looked toward the window.

"No.""

Gabriel picked up his phone.

"I'm calling her.""

Laura grabbed his wrist.

"Wait.""

He stared at her.

"Why?""

"Because Vivian already knows I've come here.""

A phone vibrated on the table.

It was Gabriel's.

A message appeared from Madeline.

Dad, Mom says you're asking questions about a woman named Sarah Carter. Is she the woman in the old hospital pictures?

Another message arrived immediately afterward.

There's something you need to know. I found a box in Mom's closet.

Then came a photograph.

It showed a yellow hospital blanket.

May you like

And beneath it, an old envelope with my mother's handwriting.

*For the two daughters I was never allowed to raise.*

Related Stories

Other posts