Amazed

Chapter 96: The Daughter Samuel Was Forced to Forget

Samuel stared at the photograph as if the little girl in his arms had reached through twenty-one years to accuse him.

I had never seen him look so broken.

"Samuel," I said quietly.

"Tell me what you remember.""

He shook his head.

"I remember a hospital. I remember Elizabeth screaming. I remember holding a baby girl.""

He touched the photograph.

"Then I remember waking up in another hospital three days later. They told me the baby had died.""

Rebecca stepped closer.

"Who told you?""

Samuel closed his eyes.

"Margaret.""

My stomach tightened.

"My mother?""

He nodded.

"She told me Elizabeth had suffered complications during childbirth. She said the baby hadn't survived. She also told me that if I ever mentioned the child again, everyone I loved would be in danger.""

I looked at the photograph again.

Elizabeth was holding another newborn.

Samuel was standing beside her, his hand resting on the baby's blanket.

And the date was twenty-one years earlier.

"That means the little girl wasn't Emma's twin," I said.

Rebecca shook her head.

"No. Look at the medical identification number.""

She enlarged the photograph.

There were two numbers written on the hospital bracelet.

One belonged to the baby Samuel was holding.

The other belonged to the baby Elizabeth was holding.

Two children.

Born during the same delivery.

I felt my chest tighten.

"Twins.""

Rebecca nodded.

"But the original records indicate something unusual. One child was registered as Elizabeth Cross, while the other was registered as Margaret Cross.""

I stared at her.

"Those are the names we've been seeing for decades.""

"Yes.""

David approached the screen.

"There's another problem. The birth dates were deliberately altered. One child was recorded as being born twenty-one years ago. The other was registered eight years ago.""

I looked at Samuel.

"Which one was yours?""

He didn't answer.

Instead, he pointed toward the photograph.

"The child in my arms.""

Rebecca examined the original hospital document.

"Samuel, according to this record, you were listed as the biological father of both children.""

He covered his mouth.

"I had two daughters.""

His voice broke.

"And Margaret told me I had lost them both.""

I walked toward him.

"Why didn't you investigate?""

He looked at me with exhausted eyes.

"Because every time I tried, someone sent me photographs of people I loved. Your mother. Elizabeth. You.

They knew where everyone lived. They knew what school you attended. They knew everything.""

I understood something then.

The family hadn't merely controlled identities.

It had controlled grief.

It had convinced parents that their children were dead, convinced children that their parents were strangers, and convinced entire generations that the truth was too dangerous to uncover.

Rebecca opened another file.

"Daniel, I found something.""

It was a scanned letter addressed to Samuel.

The date was twenty-one years earlier.

He took it with trembling fingers.

The handwriting belonged to Elizabeth.

*Samuel, if they tell you our daughters are dead, don't believe them. One has been taken to the Crosswell estate. The other has been placed with a family who will raise her under another name.

I cannot tell you where they are. But I promise you that both girls are alive.*

Samuel lowered the letter.

"She knew.""

I nodded.

"Elizabeth tried to save them.""

A second document appeared.

It contained the original names of the twins.

The first was Elizabeth Cross.

The second was Emma Cross.

I stopped breathing.

"Emma?""

Rebecca nodded.

"Not your Emma's current birth record. This is the original designation. The name was assigned to the second twin before the records were altered.""

I looked at the photograph of the little girl.

The girl standing beside Margaret in the latest message had Emma's face.

But the photograph was twenty-one years old.

Something was wrong.

Then David discovered a handwritten annotation beneath the records.

"Daniel, look at this.""

It read:

THE ORIGINAL CHILDREN WERE NEVER REPLACED. THEIR IDENTITIES WERE.

I stared.

That meant the girls hadn't been switched physically.

Their documents had been exchanged.

Their ages had been rewritten.

Their family histories had been manufactured.

And the little girl everyone called Elizabeth Cross might actually be the daughter Samuel had been told was dead.

My phone rang.

The screen displayed an unfamiliar number.

I answered.

"Daniel.""

A little girl's voice came through.

"Daddy?""

My heart stopped.

"Emma?""

"No. It's me.""

I couldn't speak.

The girl continued.

"Grandma says I shouldn't call you. She says you won't remember me.""

Samuel grabbed the phone.

"Sweetheart?""

Silence.

Then a trembling voice answered.

"Daddy?""

Samuel sank into a chair.

"My baby.""

I looked toward Rebecca.

She was already tracing the call.

The girl whispered something.

"Grandma is taking me to the old house. She says the eighth child has to choose which family gets to keep her.""

I clenched my fists.

"Listen to me. Nobody is choosing anything for you. Do you understand?""

A door slammed in the background.

The girl began crying.

Then another voice interrupted.

Margaret.

"Daniel, you should have stayed away.""

"Where is Emma?""

"Your daughter is safe.""

"Which daughter?""

Margaret laughed softly.

"Now you're beginning to understand.""

I looked at Samuel.

He was staring at the photograph.

Then Margaret said something that changed everything.

"The little girl you're speaking to is Elizabeth. And the child you call Emma is the one I was supposed to give Samuel twenty-one years ago.""

The call disconnected.

Rebecca looked at me.

"Daniel, we have to get to the estate.""

I grabbed my jacket.

"Get Collins. Get the security team. And contact the authorities.""

Samuel stood.

"I'm coming.""

I looked at him.

"You're not going to face her alone.""

He shook his head.

"I'm not going to lose another daughter.""

As we headed toward the door, Rebecca's computer chimed.

A final document had appeared.

It was the original delivery report.

Two babies.

Two fathers listed.

And beneath their names, a handwritten sentence:

THE THIRD CHILD WAS NEVER BORN IN THE HOSPITAL.

I stopped.

"Third child?""

Rebecca looked up.

Then she turned the monitor toward me.

There was a photograph of a newborn baby.

The child's face was partially covered.

But the name beneath it was unmistakable.

DANIEL CROSS.

I stared at the screen.

Samuel whispered:

"Daniel, I think your entire life was built around protecting a child who was never supposed to exist.""

And suddenly, I understood why Margaret had spent so many years trying to control our family.

May you like

She hadn't simply been hiding the children.

She had been hiding the reason they existed.

Related Stories

Other posts