Amazed

Chapter 8: The Name on the Insurance Policy

I drove home without saying a word.

Marcus sat beside me, occasionally glancing in my direction.

The name kept repeating in my head.

Vanessa.

My fiancée had been named as the secondary beneficiary on Emily's life insurance policy.

How?

Why?

I called Laura as soon as I reached home.

“Explain exactly what you found.””

“Emily updated her policy about five weeks before her death. Vanessa was listed as a contingent beneficiary under a specific condition.””

“What condition?””

“If you and Lily were both unable to receive the proceeds, Vanessa would become eligible to receive them as the designated guardian.””

I gripped the steering wheel.

“Emily would never have chosen Vanessa.””

“Daniel, I agree the timing is suspicious. But we need the original authorization records.””

“Can you get them?””

“I'm already requesting them.””

That evening, I searched through my old emails.

I found several messages from Emily's insurance company, including a confirmation notice.

The document showed that Emily had requested a beneficiary update.

But the signature looked wrong.

It wasn't obviously forged.

It simply didn't resemble her usual handwriting.

I forwarded it to Laura.

Then I called Rebecca.

“Do you remember Vanessa ever discussing Emily's insurance?””

Rebecca was quiet.

“Actually, yes.””

“When?””

“About a month before Emily died, Vanessa asked whether I knew anything about beneficiary changes. I thought it was an unusual question.””

“Did she mention my wife?””

“She said Emily had made some complicated financial arrangements and that she was trying to help Patricia understand them.””

I closed my eyes.

Vanessa had been involved before I even knew her.

I spent the next morning at Laura's office.

She had arranged for a document examiner to review the signature.

But before the examiner arrived, another email came through.

It was from Rebecca.

This time, she had attached a series of photographs from an old work event.

Vanessa was standing beside Patricia.

A man stood with them.

I recognized him immediately.

He was a financial adviser named Gregory Shaw.

I had met him once at a charity fundraiser.

Laura examined the photograph.

“Do you know him?””

“He helped Emily with some investment paperwork.””

Laura looked up.

“Are you sure?””

I nodded.

“Emily mentioned him once. She said he had been recommended by Patricia.””

Laura opened another document.

“Interesting.””

“What?””

“Gregory Shaw was the witness listed on the beneficiary change.””

I felt sick.

The examiner arrived shortly afterward.

She compared the signature samples.

After reviewing them, she looked at Laura.

“I can't make a final determination from copies, but there are inconsistencies. The signature on the beneficiary change appears to have been traced or mechanically reproduced.””

My mouth went dry.

“Are you saying someone forged my wife's signature?””

“I'm saying the document needs a full forensic examination.””

Laura immediately requested the original records.

Then she gave me another piece of information.

“Daniel, Vanessa's attorney contacted me this morning.””

I frowned.

“What did he want?””

“He claims Vanessa intends to seek financial compensation because you canceled the wedding.””

I stared at her.

“Compensation?””

“He says she paid for certain expenses and suffered reputational damage.””

I almost laughed.

“She hit my daughter.””

“That will be central to our response. But there's something else.””

Laura slid a document across the desk.

It was a draft financial settlement.

Vanessa was requesting payment for wedding expenses, emotional distress, and alleged promises of future financial support.

The total was nearly $180,000.

I looked at the final page.

There was a paragraph about Lily.

It stated that Vanessa had developed a parental relationship with my daughter and should be compensated for the emotional harm caused by being abruptly removed from her life.

I pushed the document away.

“She wants money for losing access to my child?””

“That's how she's framing it.””

I stood up.

“Then she can explain that to a judge.””

Before leaving, Laura handed me a copy of the insurance document.

“We need to establish who submitted this and whether Emily authorized it.””

I drove home.

Lily was waiting at the front window.

When she saw my car, she ran outside.

“Daddy!””

I caught her in my arms.

“Hey, princess.””

She held up a drawing.

It showed our house, me, and her.

There was another person in the picture.

A woman with brown hair.

“Who's that?”” I asked.

“Mommy.””

I smiled.

Then she pointed toward the bottom corner.

“And that's the lady who came to Mommy's room.””

My smile disappeared.

“What lady?””

Lily pointed at the woman.

“The one who brought the shiny box.””

I knelt.

“What shiny box?””

“The little box Mommy didn't want her to take.””

I looked at her carefully.

“Do you remember what the lady looked like?””

Lily nodded.

“She had yellow hair.””

My heart began pounding.

“Was it Vanessa?””

Lily looked at me.

Then she shook her head.

“No, Daddy.””

She pointed at the drawing again.

“It's the other lady.””

I stared at the brown-haired figure.

Then Lily whispered:

“It's the lady from the hospital.””

I felt the ground shift beneath me.

Because the only other woman who had visited Emily at the hospital before she died was someone I hadn't thought about in years.

May you like

My wife's older sister.

*Claire.*

Related Stories

Other posts