Chapter 4: The Boy in the Family Photograph
I turned toward Chloe.
“Have I met the father of your baby?””
She pressed her lips together.
“Chloe, look at me.””
Her eyes rose slowly to mine.
“Yes.””
My mind raced through every boy who had ever come to our apartment. The classmates who had crowded around the kitchen table doing homework. The teenager who had helped carry groceries upstairs last winter. The quiet boy who had once stood in our doorway holding a science project while I hurried past him on my way to work.
“Who is Ethan?””
Chloe glanced at Daniel.
He shook his head slightly, a warning I couldn't miss.
“Don't look at him,” I said.
“Look at me.””
She swallowed.
“Ethan Miller.””
The name meant nothing at first.
Then I remembered the Miller family.
Their son attended Chloe's school. His mother worked as a receptionist at a dental office, and his father coached youth baseball. I'd met them at a school fundraiser the previous fall, where I'd spent twenty minutes stacking paper plates while other parents chatted over coffee.
Ethan had been standing beside Chloe near the gym doors.
He'd smiled politely when I introduced myself.
I remembered telling him to make sure Chloe got home before dark.
I remembered him saying, “Yes, ma'am.””
I remembered how ordinary the moment had seemed.
“How old is he?”” I asked.
Chloe hesitated.
“Fifteen.””
“Your age?””
She nodded.
Daniel cleared his throat.
“Mara, there's no point interrogating her.””
I turned on him.
“You have had months to talk about this. I have had twenty minutes. You will let me ask my daughter questions.””
He closed his mouth.
I faced Chloe again.
“Did he know you were pregnant?””
“Yes.””
“Did he go to the appointment with you?””
She shook her head.
“Then who went with you?””
“Uncle Daniel.””
I closed my eyes briefly.
“Why Ethan? Why didn't you tell me when you first found out?””
She twisted the hem of her sweatshirt.
“Because I thought you'd hate me.””
“Why would I hate you?””
“Because I messed everything up.””
“You are fifteen years old. You haven't messed up your entire life.””
“But I'm pregnant!””
Her shout startled all three of us.
She pressed both hands to her face.
“I know what people say about girls like me. I know what happens when people find out. They'll whisper at school, and teachers will look at me differently, and everyone will think I'm stupid.””
I sat beside her.
“Chloe, listen to me. You are not stupid.””
“You're disappointed.””
“I am scared. I'm worried. I'm trying to understand what happened. But those things are not the same as hating you.””
She studied me.
“Would you have said that in May?””
The question stopped me.
I wanted to answer immediately.
I wanted to tell her that I would have held her, found a doctor, called the school, and made sure she knew she wasn't alone.
But I couldn't honestly promise that the first few minutes would have been gentle.
I might have panicked. I might have cried. I might have asked questions too quickly and said things I regretted.
Chloe deserved honesty, not another promise designed to make her feel better.
“I might have been scared enough to say the wrong thing,” I admitted.
“But I would have wanted to help you.””
She looked down.
“I know that now.””
I reached for her hand.
“Tell me about Ethan.””
She rubbed her thumb over a loose thread on her sleeve.
“We started talking last winter. We had a science project together. He was nice to me, and he listened when I talked.””
I felt the sting of those last words, but I didn't interrupt.
“He never made fun of me when I got things wrong. He remembered stuff I told him. He knew I liked drawing, and he asked to see my sketchbook.””
“What happened in May?””
Her cheeks flushed.
“We made a mistake.””
I kept my voice gentle.
“I need you to tell me whether you felt pressured or whether anyone hurt you.””
She shook her head quickly.
“No. Ethan didn't force me to do anything.””
“Did you feel you could say no?””
“Yes.””
“Are you sure?””
She nodded.
I took a slow breath.
“Okay. I'm glad you told me.””
Daniel shifted beside the doorway.
“I told you she wasn't in danger.””
I looked at him sharply.
“You didn't know that. You didn't ask enough questions to know that.””
He looked away.
Chloe reached into the pocket of her sweatshirt and pulled out a folded sheet of paper.
“Ethan gave me this.””
I opened it carefully.
It was a page torn from a notebook, covered in uneven handwriting.
*Chloe, I'm sorry. I don't know how to tell my parents. I want to help you, but I'm scared they'll send me away.
Uncle Daniel says your mom is already struggling, and if she finds out, she'll blame you for ruining her life. He says we should wait until we're sure what we're going to do.*
I read it twice.
At the bottom, Ethan had added:
Please don't think I'm leaving you.
My eyes lifted to Daniel.
“You told Ethan I would blame my daughter?””
“I was trying to prevent a disaster.””
“You convinced two frightened teenagers that the person they needed most was the person they should hide from.””
Daniel's expression hardened.
“You weren't available, Mara.””
“Then you should have helped me become available. You should have called me. You should have knocked on my door and told me my child was in trouble.””
“And what would you have done?”” he demanded.
“Quit your job? Stop paying rent? Magically become two people?””
“I don't know!”” I shouted.
“But I would have been her mother!””
The room fell silent.
Daniel stared at me.
For the first time that night, he seemed to have no answer.
Then Chloe reached for the notebook page.
“There's more.””
I looked at her.
“What do you mean?””
She pulled another folded sheet from her pocket.
“This is why Uncle Daniel told me not to tell you.””
She placed it on the coffee table.
It was a printed text conversation between Daniel and Ethan. Several messages had been highlighted in yellow.
The first was from Daniel.
Don't tell Mara yet. She'll panic and make things worse.
Ethan had replied:
But Chloe wants to tell her.
Daniel's next message read:
Give me a little time. I know someone who can help us.
My stomach tightened.
I read the exchange again.
“Who were you talking about?”” I asked.
Daniel looked toward the door.
“No one important.””
“Then why did you tell them to keep this from me?””
He said nothing.
I held up the paper.
“Who were you planning to bring into my daughter's life without my knowledge?””
Daniel's jaw flexed.
Finally, he looked at Chloe.
“I was trying to find someone who could take the baby.””
The words seemed to suck all the air out of the apartment.
Chloe recoiled as if he had struck her.
“What?””
Daniel stepped toward her.
“Listen to me. I was trying to give you options.””
“You said you would help me!””
“I am helping you!””
“You said nobody would take my baby!””
His face went pale.
I stared at my brother.
“You discussed giving my daughter's baby to someone else?””
“I never agreed to anything!””
“But you were looking.””
Daniel looked down at the highlighted messages.
For several seconds, none of us spoke.
Then he reached into his jacket pocket and pulled out an envelope.
He set it on the table.
Inside was a printed photograph of a smiling middle-aged couple standing in front of a white house with a wide porch.
Beneath it was a letter.
I read the first line.
We understand the situation is difficult, and we would be grateful for the opportunity to provide a loving home.
My hands began to shake again.
At the bottom of the letter was a name I recognized.
Not from school.
Not from the neighborhood.
From my own family.
The couple's letter was signed by my brother's closest friends, Rebecca and Paul.
People who had sat at our Thanksgiving table.
People who had watched Chloe grow up.
People who had never once asked me whether I wanted to be part of this decision.
I looked at Daniel.
“Did you promise them anything?””
He opened his mouth.
Before he could answer, Chloe whispered, “Mom, there's something I haven't told you about Rebecca.””
May you like
She reached for my hand.
“She's the one who gave me the second pregnancy test.””