Chapter 5: The Woman in the Family Photograph

Diane was waiting outside my house when I returned that afternoon.
Her black Mercedes sat beneath the old oak tree.
She stood on the front porch wearing a cream-colored coat, holding a casserole dish like she was arriving for Sunday dinner.
For a moment, I almost saw the little girl I grew up with.
The same girl who used to steal peaches from our mother's kitchen and hide them beneath her bed.
Then I remembered the recording.
I opened the front door but didn't invite her inside.
“Why are you here?””
She raised the dish.
“I brought food. I thought you might not have eaten.””
“I've been busy.””
“Christopher, please. Can we talk like adults?””
“We can talk here.””
Her eyes moved over my shoulder, searching the hallway.
“Are you alone?””
I said nothing.
She gave me a thin smile.
“I heard about Nathan.””
“What did you hear?””
“That he's been arrested.””
“He's cooperating with investigators.””
Her expression changed.
Just slightly.
But I saw it.
“You shouldn't encourage him,” she said.
“He's confused and frightened.””
“He's also an adult.””
“He made mistakes.””
“So did Zachary.””
Diane's jaw tightened.
“Zachary built a successful company. He gave Hannah a life most women could only dream about.””
I looked at her.
“My daughter didn't need a mansion. She needed to feel safe in her own home.””
Diane shifted the casserole dish.
“Women sometimes exaggerate when marriages break down.””
I stepped closer.
“Would you like to explain the bruises?””
She looked away.
“I'm not discussing this on the porch.””
“Then leave.””
She suddenly lowered her voice.
“You have no idea what you're dragging into the open.””
I held her gaze.
“Then explain it.””
For the first time, she looked genuinely frightened.
“I protected this family.””
“From what?””
“From Elizabeth's mistakes.””
My heartbeat changed.
“What mistakes?””
Diane swallowed.
Then she looked directly into my eyes.
“You should have listened to me seven years ago.””
I felt my entire body go cold.
“What happened to my wife?””
Diane stepped backward.
“Not here.””
“Where, Diane? Where should we discuss the fact that you just admitted knowing something about her death?””
She turned toward the driveway.
“Don't call the police on me, Christopher.””
“I haven't.””
“Not yet.””
She opened the car door.
Before getting in, she looked back.
“Ask Nathan what he found in the old insurance records. Then ask yourself why Elizabeth changed her will shortly before she died.””
The Mercedes pulled away.
I stood on the porch until the sound of the engine disappeared.
Then I called Detective Bell.
He answered immediately.
“Detective, Diane was just here.””
“What did she say?””
I repeated the conversation.
There was a pause.
“Don't go looking for anything yourself. We're requesting the original insurance and estate records.””
“There's something about my wife's death.””
“We'll investigate it.””
I ended the call and walked into my study.
The room looked exactly as Elizabeth had left it years earlier. The books were still arranged alphabetically. Her old reading glasses sat in the top drawer. A photograph of the two of us stood beside the desk.
I picked it up.
Elizabeth had been smiling.
She had one arm around Hannah, who was seventeen in the picture, and Nathan stood on her other side.
Diane was behind them, holding a glass of champagne.
The photograph had been taken at Hannah's high school graduation.
Everyone looked happy.
Everyone looked safe.
I placed it back on the desk.
Then I opened the cabinet where I kept the old family documents.
There were tax records, insurance policies, and property deeds. Most had not been touched since Elizabeth died.
I searched through the folders until I found the insurance file.
A life insurance policy worth two million dollars.
The beneficiary was me.
But attached to the policy was a handwritten amendment.
I recognized Elizabeth's handwriting.
The document appeared to have been signed eleven days before her death.
I read the first line.
In the event of my death under circumstances involving an accident, my husband should not accept any settlement without an independent investigation.
I stared at it.
Elizabeth had known she might die in an accident?
My phone rang.
Nathan.
I answered.
“What's wrong?””
His voice was urgent.
“Dad, the detective let me see something from the records. There's a reason Diane told you to look at the insurance documents.””
“What reason?””
“They found a payment.””
“From whom?””
“An insurance company. It was made after Mom died.””
I looked down at the handwritten amendment.
“How much?””
Nathan hesitated.
“Two million dollars.””
I felt a chill crawl up my spine.
“Who received it?””
“Dad, that's the thing.””
His breathing became uneven.
“The money wasn't paid to you.””
I gripped the edge of the desk.
“Then who received it?””
Nathan's voice dropped to a whisper.
“A company owned by Aunt Diane.””
For several seconds, I couldn't speak.
Then he said the one thing I hadn't been prepared to hear.
“Dad, there's a second insurance policy. And that one was opened in your name.””
I looked at the family photograph.
Elizabeth smiling.
Hannah smiling.
Nathan smiling.
And Diane standing behind all of them.
“What does the second policy say?”” I asked.
Nathan went silent.
Then he answered.
“It names you as the insured person, Dad.””
A cold sensation spread through my chest.
“When was it opened?””
“Six months before Mom died.””
I looked toward the front door, where my sister had stood only minutes earlier.
Six months before Elizabeth died, someone had quietly taken out a life insurance policy on me.
And the person who owned the company receiving my wife's insurance money was the same woman who had just warned me to stop asking questions.
Diane Montgomery.
My own sister.
I called Detective Bell again.
This time, I didn't need to explain why.
He answered, and I said four words:
“Check the second policy.””
There was a pause.
Then he asked:
“Colonel, are you somewhere safe?””
Before I could answer, my front doorbell rang.
I walked toward the window.
A uniformed officer stood on my porch.
Behind him was a woman holding a large brown envelope.
I recognized her immediately.
May you like
She was the attorney who had handled Elizabeth's estate.
And she was carrying a photograph of my late wife that I had never seen before.