Chapter 4: The Woman in the Photograph

Ethan arrived in an ambulance twenty minutes later.
I recognized his dinosaur pajamas before I recognized his face.
He was lying on a stretcher, wrapped in a gray hospital blanket. His cheeks were flushed, his lips were dry, and a paramedic was checking his pulse.
“Daddy!””
I rushed toward him.
“Buddy! Daddy's here!””
He reached both arms toward me.
I lifted him carefully, avoiding his injured leg.
“I'm here, little man. You're safe.””
He buried his face against my shoulder.
“I'm sorry, Daddy.””
My heart broke.
“Why are you sorry?””
“Mommy said I made trouble.””
I closed my eyes.
“No, buddy. You didn't make trouble.””
Ethan began crying.
“Maya gave me crackers.””
I looked at my daughter, who had been brought into the adjoining treatment area.
She was crying too.
The siblings reached for each other.
For a moment, the entire hospital seemed to disappear.
Then a doctor gently asked me to put Ethan back on the stretcher.
“We need to treat his leg and assess his hydration,” she explained.
“He also needs a full evaluation.””
I nodded.
“Whatever you need.””
Claire remained in the hallway with an officer.
She had stopped crying.
Instead, she kept asking whether she could speak to me privately.
I refused.
Then Officer Reynolds approached.
“Mr. Bennett, we recovered several items from your basement. There's something you should see.””
He showed me a photograph on his phone.
It was the wooden storage shelf Claire had mentioned.
One side had collapsed.
Beside it was a locked metal cabinet.
“What is that?”” I asked.
“Your wife says it's an old family storage cabinet.””
I looked at the photograph.
A small section of the cabinet door appeared damaged, as if someone had recently tried to force it open.
Officer Reynolds continued.
“We also found a key in your wife's purse.””
“Did you open it?””
“Not yet. We're documenting the scene.””
I thought about the broken wooden box.
The photograph of Claire with the unknown man.
And the documents bearing her mother's name.
“There's something else,” I said.
“My daughter said the box contained papers with her grandmother's name.””
The officer nodded.
“That's consistent with some of the documents we recovered.””
I stared at him.
“What does that mean?””
“We're still determining that.””
I returned to the treatment room.
Maya was sitting beside Ethan, holding his uninjured hand.
I pulled a chair closer.
“Sweetheart, can I ask you about the photograph?””
She nodded.
“Do you know the man standing beside Mommy?””
Maya looked at the picture.
“That's Uncle Daniel.””
I froze.
“Uncle Daniel?””
She nodded.
I had never heard of an Uncle Daniel.
Claire had told me her father died before she was born, and that she had no siblings.
“Where did you meet him?””
“In the basement.””
My throat tightened.
“Was he there today?””
“No.””
“Did you ever see him before?””
She nodded again.
“Sometimes Mommy talks to him on the phone.””
I looked at the photograph.
The man had one arm around Claire. They looked comfortable together.
“Did Mommy tell you who he was?””
Maya shook her head.
“She said he was a secret.””
I turned toward the door.
Claire was standing outside with Officer Reynolds.
I stepped into the hallway.
“Who is Daniel?””
Claire's face changed.
“Marcus, please.””
“Your daughter just identified him as Uncle Daniel.””
She looked at Maya through the glass.
Then she whispered, “He's my brother.””
I stared at her.
“You told me you were an only child.””
“I know.””
“Why?””
“Because my family is complicated.””
“Complicated? Claire, your brother has been secretly involved in our children's lives, and I didn't even know he existed!””
She rubbed her forehead.
“Daniel made mistakes.””
“What kind of mistakes?””
“He was in trouble years ago. My mother cut him off.””
“Then why is his picture in a box you were so desperate to hide?””
Claire didn't answer.
Officer Reynolds approached.
“Mrs. Bennett, we'd like to ask you some additional questions about the contents of that cabinet.””
She immediately shook her head.
“You can't open it.””
“Why not?””
“Because what's inside belongs to my mother.””
The officer looked at me.
Then he asked Claire a question that made her go completely still.
“Ma'am, why does the cabinet contain a second birth certificate for a child named Ethan Bennett?””
I felt the air leave my lungs.
Ethan was our son.
I knew his birthday. I had been in the delivery room. I had signed his hospital paperwork.
“What second birth certificate?””
Claire looked at the floor.
May you like
And then she whispered:
“Because Ethan isn't the first child with that name.””