Amazed

Chapter 2: The Paper Nobody Was Supposed to Find

The judge ordered everyone to remain seated.

Sarah looked as though someone had pulled the floor out from beneath her.

"Your Honor, this is a ridiculous distraction," she said.

"My daughter doesn't understand what she's carrying.""

Robert didn't look away from the document.

"Then perhaps Ms. Carter can explain why she has a written list of allegations that haven't happened yet.""

A murmur spread through the courtroom.

Judge Whitmore extended her hand.

"Mr. Hayes, bring that document forward.""

Robert walked to the bench.

Sarah's attorney immediately objected.

"We have no way of knowing where that paper came from.""

"Neither do I," the judge replied.

"That's why I'm asking to examine it.""

An officer carefully took the document from Robert.

I couldn't see the writing from where I sat.

But I could see Sarah.

Her fingers were trembling.

That was the first time in six months I had seen her look genuinely afraid.

Emily tugged at my sleeve.

"Daddy?""

I turned toward her.

"Yes, sweetheart?""

"Did I do something bad?""

My heart broke.

"No, baby. You didn't do anything wrong.""

"But Mommy said I shouldn't show anybody.""

I swallowed.

"Sometimes grown-ups tell children things they don't understand. You did the right thing by asking for help.""

Sarah suddenly rushed toward us.

"Emily, come here!""

One officer stepped between her and my daughter.

"Ma'am, please return to your seat.""

"She's my child!""

Judge Whitmore struck her gavel.

"Ms. Carter, sit down immediately.""

Sarah reluctantly returned to her chair.

The judge examined the paper for nearly a minute.

Then she looked at the prosecutor.

"Mr. Reeves, do you recognize this handwriting?""

Daniel Reeves stood.

"I cannot identify it from here, Your Honor.""

"Come forward.""

He approached the bench.

The judge showed him the bottom of the document.

His expression changed.

I noticed it.

So did Robert.

"Is something wrong?"" the judge asked.

Reeves cleared his throat.

"No, Your Honor.""

Robert stood.

"I'd like the record to reflect that the document contains the name of Mr. Reeves's lead witness, a woman named Denise Palmer.""

Sarah's attorney shifted in his chair.

Denise Palmer was Sarah's best friend.

She had testified that she witnessed me threatening Sarah outside our house.

According to her statement, I had shouted that Sarah would regret taking Emily away from me.

I had never said those words.

I had never even seen Denise that evening.

Robert continued.

"The paper also contains a handwritten instruction to make sure Ms. Palmer repeats the exact same statement in court.""

The judge looked directly at Sarah.

"Ms. Carter, did you write this?""

"No.""

"Do you know who did?""

"I have no idea.""

Robert lifted another page.

"Then perhaps you can explain this.""

He placed a photograph beside the document.

It showed a kitchen drawer.

Inside were several envelopes, a red marker, and a small black notebook.

The photograph had been attached to the paper.

Sarah's face went pale.

I leaned toward Robert.

"Where did that come from?""

He whispered, "I don't know yet.""

The judge ordered a recess.

As the officers began moving me toward the holding area, Emily started crying.

"Daddy! Don't go!""

I turned around as far as the cuffs allowed.

"I'll see you soon, princess.""

"Promise?""

"I promise.""

Sarah grabbed Emily's hand.

"Come on. We're leaving.""

Emily pulled away.

"I want Daddy!""

Sarah bent down, gripping her daughter's shoulders.

"Stop embarrassing me.""

The words were quiet.

But I heard them.

And so did Robert.

He immediately looked toward the court reporter.

"Your Honor, I'd like that last exchange noted.""

Sarah froze.

During the recess, Robert met me in a small conference room.

He placed the photograph on the table.

"Michael, I need you to answer something honestly.""

"Ask me.""

"Have you ever seen that notebook?""

"No.""

"Have you ever seen the drawer?""

I studied the photograph.

It was from Sarah's old house.

The house where we had lived before our separation.

Then I noticed something familiar.

The red marker.

It was the same brand Emily had used to draw the heart on my cheek.

"Robert, I think Emily took this from Sarah's bedroom.""

"Why?""

"Because Sarah always kept important documents in the bottom drawer of her dresser. She had a little lockbox there.""

Robert stared at the photograph.

"Do you know what's inside the lockbox?""

I shook my head.

"Not anymore.""

He rubbed his forehead.

"Michael, if this is what it appears to be, your custody case could change completely.""

Before I could respond, the conference room door opened.

A court officer stepped inside.

"Mr. Hayes, the judge wants you back in the courtroom.""

Robert stood.

"Did she say why?""

The officer hesitated.

"She received a call from the courthouse investigator.""

Then he looked directly at me.

"Apparently, someone has already reported that the document Emily brought into court was stolen.""

Robert frowned.

"Who reported it?""

The officer handed him a small piece of paper.

"Your client's ex-wife.""

I stared at the name written beneath the complaint.

Sarah hadn't just accused me of being dangerous.

She was now accusing our five-year-old daughter of stealing evidence.

And suddenly, I understood something.

May you like

Sarah wasn't afraid of what Emily had found.

She was afraid of what Emily might remember.

Related Stories

Other posts