Amazed

Chapter 14: The Second Mother

Mark moved between Michael and the couch so quickly that Sophie barely had time to sit up.

“Stay there.””

Michael froze.

“I will.””

Sophie rubbed her eyes.

“Why is Mikey here?””

Mark looked at me.

I knelt beside her.

“You’ve met him before?””

“At the white house.””

“How many times?””

She held up three fingers.

Michael whispered, “Four.””

Mark spun.

“Don’t correct my daughter.””

“I’m not.””

“Then shut up.””

Ramirez stepped closer.

“Mr. Vale, you’re going to answer questions, but not while standing over a five-year-old.””

Michael nodded.

“I understand.””

Sophie tugged my sleeve.

“Is Mikey in trouble?””

“I don’t know yet.””

“He cries a lot.””

Michael looked away.

I carried Sophie upstairs.

Mom followed.

As I tucked Sophie into bed, she asked, “Is Emily coming?””

“Not tonight.””

“Can she come tomorrow?””

My chest hurt.

“We’ll see.””

“She misses me.””

“How do you know?””

“She told me.””

“When?””

“Last time.””

“At the white house?””

“Yes.””

“What did you talk about?””

“Her mommy.””

I sat very still.

“What did Emily say about her mommy?””

“She said her mommy watches us from the other room.””

“Anna?””

Sophie shrugged.

“Did you ever meet her?””

“No.””

“Did Emily tell you her name?””

“Annie.””

Close enough.

“What did Emily say about Annie?””

Sophie pulled the blanket to her chin.

“She said Annie cries when she sees me.””

“Why?””

“Because I look like somebody.””

“Who?””

Sophie yawned.

“Aunt Claire.””

My heart stopped.

“Emily knows my name?””

“Uh-huh.””

“How?””

“Her mommy has your pictures.””

I stared at her.

“What pictures?””

“Lots.””

“From where?””

“Our house.””

A cold sensation moved through me.

“Pictures taken through the windows?””

“No.””

She shook her head sleepily.

“Old pictures.””

“What old pictures?””

“You when you were little.””

I looked at Mom.

Her face had gone blank.

“Where would Anna get my childhood photographs?””

“I don’t know.””

“Dad?””

Mom whispered, “Maybe.””

Sophie closed her eyes.

I kissed her forehead.

When we returned downstairs, Michael was seated at the kitchen table with Ramirez opposite him.

David stood near the wall.

Two men with the same stolen name.

One my biological brother.

One potentially my daughter’s biological father.

My life had become impossible to explain in a single sentence.

I sat.

“Start at the beginning.””

Michael looked at Ramirez.

She nodded.

He clasped his hands.

“My father raised me inside the research world. By sixteen, I knew how to process samples. By twenty-two, I was working in his laboratory.””

“Did you know about David?””

“No.””

David laughed without humor.

“Apparently I was a surprise.””

Michael looked at him.

“I’m sorry.””

“Save it.””

Michael continued.

“I believed MV-001 was simply my research identifier. I submitted blood, tissue, reproductive samples—everything.””

“Why?””

“Because Leonard told me I carried a rare protective variant.””

“Against Daniel’s disorder?””

“Yes.””

“And he wanted to study it.””

“Yes.””

“When did you learn he was creating embryos?””

“Five years ago.””

“The year Sophie was born.””

“Yes.””

“How?””

“Anna contacted me.””

David crossed his arms.

“She found you before she found me?””

“She found both of us around the same time.””

I looked at David.

“You didn’t mention that.””

“You didn’t ask.””

I almost threw something at him.

“No more technical truths.””

He lowered his eyes.

Michael continued.

“Anna had obtained internal records showing two embryo lines.””

“C-17?””

“And A-12.””

“Claire and Anna.””

“Yes.””

“Both fertilized with your sperm.””

“Yes.””

“Without your consent.””

“Yes.””

“Without mine.””

“Yes.””

“Without Anna’s.””

Michael hesitated.

“No.””

The room changed.

“What?””

“Anna consented.””

My mother whispered, “Why?””

“Because she was sick.””

“From the mutation?””

“She was having severe episodes. She believed if the research could produce a child who carried Daniel’s family traits without the dangerous expression, it might lead to treatment.””

I felt sick.

“So she volunteered an embryo?””

“She volunteered eggs.””

“Did she know they were using your sperm?””

“No.””

“Did she know you were her half-brother?””

Michael looked horrified.

“Anna and I are not related.””

I turned toward David.

“Wait.””

David nodded.

“Michael is Leonard’s biological son. Anna is Daniel’s daughter.””

Right.

The family tree in my head had become a knot.

Michael continued.

“When Anna learned they had used my sperm, she wanted everything destroyed.””

“But it wasn’t.””

“No.””

“What happened to the embryos?””

“They were supposedly stored.””

“Supposedly?””

“I later discovered both had been marked as transferred.””

“To whom?””

“That’s the mystery.””

“What does transferred mean?””

“In fertility records, usually transferred into a patient.””

My skin went cold.

“You’re saying two women were implanted.””

“Possibly.””

“But I wasn’t.””

“I know.””

“How do you know?””

“Because C-17 was transferred under another patient number.””

“Whose?””

“I never found out.””

“And A-12?””

“Same problem.””

Mark leaned forward.

“Then Claire couldn’t have given birth to either embryo.””

Michael looked at me.

“That’s what I believed.””

“Until?””

“Until Anna showed me Claire’s pregnancy records.””

I stared.

“What was wrong with them?””

“Your estimated conception date.””

“What about it?””

“It matched the transfer window.””

“That proves nothing.””

“No.””

“Then why did it matter?””

“Because the doctor who recorded your pregnancy was Leonard.””

I turned toward Mom.

She whispered, “Your regular doctor was away.””

I remembered.

A substitute physician.

A quick appointment.

Congratulations.

Prenatal vitamins.

Nothing suspicious.

“I still wasn’t implanted.””

Michael nodded.

“That’s the question I couldn’t answer.””

“Then answer one you can. Who gave birth to Emily?””

“Anna.””

“And Sophie?””

“You.””

“Then why does Sophie look genetically like my niece?””

Michael’s eyes shifted toward my mother.

“Because C-17 may not have contained your egg.””

I gripped the table.

“David told me that.””

“We found evidence the identifiers were switched before fertilization.””

“By whom?””

“Leonard.””

A voice came from the doorway.

“No.””

We all turned.

Dr. Mercer stood there with another officer.

Her face was pale.

“Leonard didn’t switch them.””

Michael stood.

“Helen?””

She looked at David first.

Something passed between them.

Then she placed a folder on the table.

“The flash drive was encrypted, but the hospital recovered a partial backup from an offline server.””

Ramirez opened the folder.

“What does it show?””

“Chain-of-custody logs.””

I stood.

“And?””

Helen looked at me.

“C-17 began as your ovarian tissue.””

Relief tried to rise.

She stopped it.

“But the egg used to create the embryo did not come from that tissue.””

“Whose?””

Helen swallowed.

“Evelyn’s.””

Nobody moved.

I turned toward my mother.

Her face emptied.

“That’s impossible.””

Helen looked at her.

“Did you undergo fertility treatment at St. Catherine’s after Michael was born?””

Mom’s lips parted.

“Yes.””

My breath caught.

“When?””

“Before Claire.””

“Were eggs collected?””

“Yes.””

I stood slowly.

“You never told me that.””

“It didn’t matter. The treatment failed. Then I became pregnant with you naturally.””

Helen shook her head.

“Some of your eggs were preserved.””

Mom gripped the table.

“No.””

“The archive log shows an older specimen was relabeled C-17.””

I tried to understand.

“If Sophie came from Mom’s egg…”

“She could appear genetically like your sibling or, depending on the exact relationships and the limitations of the initial analysis, produce an unexpected close-relative result.””

“My daughter could biologically be my sister.””

Nobody answered.

I laughed.

Not because it was funny.

Because there was nowhere else for the horror to go.

Mark whispered, “Jesus.””

Michael stared at Helen.

“Then whose egg was A-12?””

“Anna’s.””

“And Emily?””

“We still need direct testing.””

Ramirez looked at Michael.

“You said you met both girls.””

“Yes.””

“Did you provide samples?””

“Yes.””

“From them?””

Michael nodded reluctantly.

“Saliva swabs.””

Mark stood.

“You swabbed my daughter?””

“She agreed.””

“She’s five!””

“I know.””

“No, you clearly don’t.””

Ramirez raised a hand.

“Results?””

Michael looked at Helen.

She shook her head.

“I haven’t seen them.””

“I have.””

Everyone turned to him.

My voice became very quiet.

“Tell me.””

Michael looked at Sophie’s baby monitor on the counter.

Then at me.

“Emily is Anna’s biological daughter.””

“And you’re her father?””

“Yes.””

I closed my eyes.

“And Sophie?””

He swallowed.

“The maternal profile matches Evelyn.””

My mother started crying.

I stared at her.

My mother.

Potentially Sophie’s biological mother.

“What about you?””

Michael didn’t answer.

“Are you Sophie’s biological father too?””

“Yes.””

The word landed like stone.

Mom whispered, “She’s my daughter.””

I turned sharply.

“No.””

Evelyn recoiled.

“I didn’t mean—”

“She is not your daughter.””

“I know.””

“She’s mine.””

“I know, Claire.””

“Say it.””

Tears ran down her face.

“Sophie is your daughter.””

I looked toward the stairs.

Five years of calling Evelyn Grandma.

Five years of calling me Mommy.

Biology could rearrange labels on paper.

It was not rearranging us.

Then Ramirez’s phone rang.

She answered.

Listened.

Her face hardened.

“Where?””

She stood.

“We’ll meet you there.””

“What happened?””

She looked at Michael.

“Margaret Cole has been found.””

I rose.

“Alive?””

“Yes.””

Relief hit me.

Then Ramirez added:

“She walked into a police station ten minutes ago carrying a little girl.””

My breath stopped.

“Emily?””

Ramirez nodded.

“Where’s Anna?””

“That’s the problem.””

“What problem?””

“Margaret says Anna disappeared yesterday.””

Michael went white.

“Disappeared?””

“Yes.””

“Who took her?””

“Margaret doesn’t know.””

My phone buzzed.

Every person in the kitchen looked at it.

Unknown number.

I opened the message.

A photograph loaded.

Anna.

Alive.

Sitting in a chair.

Not tied.

Not visibly injured.

Behind her was a wall covered in photographs.

My father.

My mother.

Me.

Sophie.

Emily.

Michael.

David.

Mark.

All connected by black lines.

May you like

Beneath the photograph was one sentence:

*You finally know who made the girls. Now ask why there had to be two.*

Related Stories

Other posts