Amazed

Chapter 9: The Second Test

Laura Mitchell read the laboratory invoice in silence.

She turned it over, examined the blacked-out name, and placed it inside a clear evidence sleeve.

“Where did you get this?”” she asked.

“Margaret found it among Daniel's files.””

“Did she explain how she obtained the file?””

“She said she discovered it after my father's funeral.””

Laura made a note.

“We'll need her to document that. For now, the invoice establishes only that a second test was requested. It doesn't establish who was tested or what the result was.””

I stared at the black marker.

“Could the laboratory still have the records?””

“Possibly. If the records were retained, there may be a way to obtain them through a proper legal request.””

“Then let's do it.””

Laura nodded.

“We'll also ask Samuel to identify the laboratory and confirm whether the reference numbers correspond to the original report.””

I sat back.

“Why would my father order a second test?””

“There are several possibilities. We shouldn't choose one until we have evidence.””

I knew she was right.

But the questions were multiplying faster than I could answer them.

Was Daniel Lily's biological father?

Had my father known the truth before Lily was born?

Had he ordered the second test because he doubted the first?

And why had someone gone to the trouble of hiding the name?

That afternoon, Laura filed a request to preserve the hospital and laboratory records. She also submitted the ownership documents to the court and requested an independent forensic review of the disputed signatures.

Two days later, we received notice of an emergency hearing.

Daniel's attorney had filed a motion accusing me of improperly obtaining confidential company records and using them to threaten his client.

I read the filing twice.

“He's trying to make me look like a criminal,” I said.

Laura sat across from me.

“He's trying to shift attention away from the ownership dispute. We will respond with the bank's access records and your father's estate documents.””

“What if the judge believes him?””

“Then we'll appeal the ruling if necessary. But I don't expect the court to ignore a properly documented ownership transfer simply because Daniel objects to its discovery.””

She slid another paper toward me.

“There's something else. Daniel's attorney has requested that Christopher be barred from contacting Lily while the paternity issue is under review.””

I looked up.

“Can he do that?””

“He can request it. Whether the court grants it depends on the evidence and the circumstances. Christopher hasn't sought contact with Lily, so the request may be premature.””

I thought about Lily's face when she asked whether she could sleep in Daniel's new pink bedroom.

She didn't need more adults fighting over her.

“Can we ask for a neutral child specialist to evaluate the situation?”” I said.

“Someone who understands how to protect her from all of this.””

Laura nodded.

“That is a reasonable request.””

The emergency hearing took place the following week.

Daniel arrived with Richard Hale and two additional attorneys. Vanessa sat in the gallery, looking exhausted. Her pregnancy was beginning to show more clearly, and she kept checking her phone.

Margaret sat several rows behind them.

She had agreed to provide a statement, but she had not yet decided whether she could testify openly about the false declaration.

Judge Whitaker entered.

“Mr. Hale, you have requested an emergency order restricting Mrs. Carter's use of certain documents. Please explain your position.””

Richard Hale stood.

“Your Honor, Mrs. Carter has obtained confidential corporate records and is using them to undermine my client's business reputation. We believe the documents may have been removed unlawfully from company premises.””

Laura rose.

“The documents were recovered from a safe-deposit box belonging to Mrs. Carter's deceased father. The bank has confirmed that access was authorized under his estate instructions. Several records are certified copies of agreements executed years before this divorce.””

Richard Hale shook his head.

“Even if the box was properly accessed, the contents may include privileged or confidential material.””

Judge Whitaker looked at Daniel.

“Mr. Carter, are you claiming these ownership agreements are fabricated?””

Daniel hesitated.

“I'm saying they don't reflect the company's current ownership structure.””

“That is not the same thing.””

“No, Your Honor.””

“Then what is your position?””

Daniel's eyes flicked toward Margaret.

“My father-in-law created a complicated arrangement. The company changed significantly after that. I believe the old agreement was superseded.””

“Do you have the superseding agreement?””

Richard Hale stood.

“We are seeking it, Your Honor.””

The judge leaned back.

“So you are asking me to prevent your wife from using documents that appear to establish her ownership while you search for a document you have not produced.””

Richard's face reddened.

“We believe there are legitimate concerns about the circumstances.””

“I will permit the forensic review and preserve all relevant records. I will not grant a blanket order preventing Mrs. Carter from presenting evidence of her ownership. As for the alleged misuse of confidential information, I see no basis for emergency sanctions at this stage.””

Daniel's jaw tightened.

Then Laura stood again.

“Your Honor, there is an additional matter. We have reason to believe that financial records were altered and company funds transferred to an entity associated with Mr. Carter's current partner.””

Vanessa looked up sharply.

Richard Hale objected.

“Your Honor, that allegation is unrelated to the current motion.””

“It may be directly relevant to the valuation of marital assets,” Laura replied.

Judge Whitaker raised a hand.

“I'm not conducting a full forensic accounting at this hearing. But I will order preservation of the relevant financial records and prohibit the transfer of disputed assets pending further review.””

Daniel whispered something to his attorney.

The judge heard him.

“Mr. Carter, if you have something to say, say it to me.””

Daniel stood.

“This is my company, Your Honor. I've spent fifteen years building it. I won't let my wife and a man who abandoned his child destroy it.””

Christopher, who had attended as a witness, remained still.

Laura rose.

“Your Honor, Mr. Carter's characterization of Mr. Vale's relationship with Lily is disputed. The court has not made any determination concerning parentage.””

“Noted,” the judge said.

“And I will not permit either party to use an unresolved paternity question as a weapon in the financial dispute.””

Daniel sat down hard.

The hearing ended with no final custody decision, but the court ordered both parties to provide updated financial disclosures and cooperate with the forensic review.

Outside, Vanessa caught up with Daniel near the elevators.

“You told me Emily was trying to steal your company,” she said.

Daniel didn't stop walking.

“She is.””

“Then why is the judge ordering you to preserve records?””

“Because he hasn't seen everything yet.””

“Daniel, I need to know what is happening with the money.””

He turned on her.

“Why?””

“Because my company received transfers from Carter Development, and now lawyers are asking questions. You told me they were consulting fees.””

“They were.””

“Then why did your accountant tell me not to touch the money?””

Daniel's face went blank.

“What accountant?””

“The accountant who called me this morning. He said the transfers were under review and that I should preserve every record.””

Daniel grabbed her phone.

“Who else have you spoken to?””

Vanessa pulled it away.

“Give it back.””

“Who?””

She stepped backward.

“You're scaring me.””

He stared at her for a long moment.

Then he lowered his voice.

“Listen carefully. If anyone asks, you received legitimate payments for consulting work. You knew nothing about the company's internal arrangements.””

“But I never did any consulting.””

Daniel went silent.

Vanessa's eyes widened.

“You told me I was helping you manage the property acquisitions.””

“You were.””

“I signed no contracts.””

“You signed what I gave you.””

She stared at him.

“You told me those papers were for the baby and the house.””

Daniel's expression hardened.

“Then you should have read them.””

Vanessa looked as though he'd slapped her.

She turned and walked away.

I had heard enough from the courthouse steps to understand that the money was beginning to unravel.

But as I followed Laura toward the parking garage, my phone rang.

Samuel.

“Emily, we found the laboratory.””

“And the second test?””

“The laboratory has an archived record, but they won't release it without a court order or authorization from the people tested.””

“Can we obtain one?””

“We've asked. There's a complication.””

“What complication?””

Samuel paused.

“The second test was not conducted on Daniel.””

I stopped walking.

“Then who was tested?””

“The records list two people. One was Christopher Vale.””

“And the other?””

Samuel's voice dropped.

“Your father.””

I felt the world go silent around me.

“My father?””

“Yes. The report was requested after the first test produced a result he apparently did not expect.””

I gripped the phone.

“Sam, why would my father take a paternity test?””

“I don't know, Emily.””

He took a breath.

“But there's a note attached to the record. It says the sample was submitted to verify a biological relationship between Robert Bennett and the child.””

I couldn't speak.

May you like

My father had ordered a test comparing his own DNA to Lily's.

And whatever he had learned, he had taken it to his grave.

Related Stories

Other posts