Amazed

Chapter 14: The Last Piece of Evidence

At eight the next morning, I met David Mercer in a small conference room at his law office.

I didn't go alone.

Detective Hayes came with me, along with my father's attorney. Dad wanted to attend, but the detective advised him to remain available for questioning about the financial records.

My mother stayed with him.

Claire wasn't invited.

I had spent the night replaying her confession, trying to separate the things she had done from the things Ethan had threatened her into doing. I still didn't know where one ended and the other began.

But I knew this much: I couldn't build a marriage on the hope that the next secret would be the last.

Mercer was a thin man in his sixties, with silver hair and a face that seemed permanently tired. He wore a navy suit and carried a leather briefcase.

He shook my hand.

"Mr. Bennett. Thank you for coming.""

"You said you had evidence about my brother's death.""

"I do.""

Detective Hayes sat beside me.

"Before we begin, I want to make it clear that any evidence relevant to the investigation must be provided to law enforcement. My client understands that," Mercer said.

He opened his briefcase and removed a sealed envelope.

Inside were three photographs, a handwritten letter, and a small cassette tape.

I stared at the tape.

"What's that?""

"A recording made by Richard Cole approximately two weeks before Michael's death.""

"How did you get it?""

"My client worked as Richard's personal assistant. She kept copies of several records after she realized what he was doing.""

"Who is your client?""

Mercer hesitated.

"Patricia Hale.""

I felt a wave of anger.

"She sent me here through you?""

"She asked me to provide the evidence to you, but she also agreed to cooperate with the police.""

"Why didn't she give this to us twenty years ago?""

"Because she was afraid. And because she believed the recording implicated someone in your family.""

Detective Hayes leaned forward.

"Let's listen to it.""

Mercer placed the cassette into a small digital converter. After a moment of static, a man's voice filled the room.

Richard Cole.

I recognized it from old interviews and business recordings.

"The boy has the documents," Richard said.

"He knows what the transfers mean.""

A second voice answered.

"Then take the documents.""

"I can't. He's already made copies.""

"Who else knows?""

"His brother.""

A pause.

Then the second voice said, "Daniel?""

"Yes.""

I gripped the edge of the table.

Richard continued.

"The younger boy saw the records. If he talks, the entire operation collapses.""

"What do you want me to do?""

"I want the records back. I want the boys frightened enough to keep quiet.""

"And if they don't?""

Silence.

Then Richard said, "Make sure they don't get the chance.""

The recording ended with a click.

Nobody spoke.

Detective Hayes replayed the final thirty seconds, then stopped the converter.

"Do we have a way to identify the second speaker?""

Mercer removed another sheet of paper.

"My client believes the voice belongs to someone who worked closely with Richard. She also provided a list of people who had access to his office.""

I studied the list.

Frank Miller was there.

So was Patricia.

But another name appeared near the bottom.

*Robert Bennett.*

I looked up.

"Why is my father's name on this list?""

Mercer folded his hands.

"Because Richard kept records of everyone involved in his financial arrangements. Your father's company received payments from accounts connected to the operation.""

"That doesn't mean he knew what they were.""

"No. But it does mean the police will need to establish what he knew and when he knew it.""

I looked at Detective Hayes.

"Do you think my father was involved in the crash?""

She answered carefully.

"We don't have evidence establishing that. The recording suggests that Richard wanted both boys silenced. It doesn't identify the person who caused the collision.""

I nodded.

"Then what else did Patricia give you?""

Mercer slid the handwritten letter across the table.

The paper was yellowed, and the ink had faded in places.

It was addressed to Richard Cole.

The letter was dated the day after Michael's death.

Richard,

I did what you asked. I recovered the keys and removed the documents from the office. Frank says the report will be handled. But the younger boy survived, and I don't know what he remembers.

You promised me no one else would be hurt.

I need you to understand that I cannot keep doing this. If you ask me to destroy anything else, I will take what I have to the authorities.

Patricia.

I read the letter twice.

"She knew I survived.""

"Yes," Mercer said.

"And she knew Frank was altering the report.""

"That's what the letter indicates.""

"Why didn't she go to the police?""

"According to my client, Richard threatened Claire. He told Patricia that if she disclosed the cover-up, he'd make sure her daughter was implicated in the financial fraud.""

I stared at the letter.

"Claire was a child.""

"Yes.""

"So Patricia protected her by helping Richard.""

Mercer didn't answer.

I understood the pattern now.

Fear had become the excuse everyone used to justify the next lie. One person threatened another, who hid something from someone else, who then made a decision that required yet another secret.

By the time the truth reached me, it had been buried under twenty years of silence.

"Where is Patricia now?"" I asked.

"At the police station, cooperating with investigators.""

"Does she have anything else?""

Mercer hesitated.

"One final document.""

He removed a folded sheet of paper from the briefcase.

It was a medical report dated the day after the accident.

My name appeared at the top.

The report described a concussion, several fractured ribs, and temporary memory loss.

At the bottom, a physician had written a note.

*Patient repeatedly asks whether older male passenger is alive. Becomes distressed when informed that passenger has died.*

I stared at the words.

Older male passenger.

Michael.

I felt my eyes burn.

There was another note beneath it.

*Patient reports seeing dark sedan. States driver exited vehicle and approached truck. Patient unable to provide further details due to confusion and head trauma.*

I looked up.

"I told them what happened.""

Mercer nodded.

"Yes. You gave a preliminary statement before your memory deteriorated. The report indicates that you saw the driver.""

"Who was it?""

"The name is not included in the medical report.""

I looked at Detective Hayes.

"Then how do we find out?""

She tapped the handwritten letter.

"We compare the timeline, the photographs, the financial records, and any remaining witness statements. We also need to locate Frank Miller and determine whether he can provide a formal account of the investigation.""

I thought about the photograph of my father beside the wreckage.

"Could my father have been the second voice on the recording?""

Mercer didn't answer immediately.

"My client says she never identified the voice with certainty. She believed it might have been your father, but she also acknowledged that several men in Richard's circle spoke similarly.""

I felt a fresh wave of dread.

My father had admitted taking money from Richard. He'd admitted arriving at the crash scene and allowing Richard to leave. But he had denied knowing about the financial fraud.

I didn't know whether he was telling the truth.

I wanted to believe he was.

But wanting to believe something wasn't proof.

Detective Hayes collected the documents and placed them in evidence sleeves.

"We'll submit the recording for forensic analysis and compare it with known voice samples. We also need to speak with Mr. Bennett again about the financial transactions.""

I nodded.

"Whatever you need.""

Mercer closed his briefcase.

"There is one more thing Patricia asked me to tell you.""

I looked at him.

"What?""

He took a breath.

"She said the person who ordered the cover-up is still alive. But she doesn't believe that person was Richard Cole.""

I felt the room grow colder.

"Then who was it?""

Mercer looked directly at me.

"Patricia believes it was someone who stood to lose everything if the records became public. Someone who knew about the money, knew about the accident, and knew your father would never willingly expose him.""

I stared at the table.

"Who?""

Mercer opened the briefcase one last time and removed a small envelope.

Inside was a photograph of a man standing beside Richard Cole outside an office building.

The date on the back was October 2006.

I recognized the man immediately.

Not from the wedding.

Not from my father's old photographs.

From my own company.

He was the attorney who had handled Bennett Holdings' incorporation, the man who'd advised me when I bought out my business partner, the person I'd trusted to review every major contract for twelve years.

My attorney.

David Mercer watched my face.

"Do you know him?""

I couldn't speak.

Because the man in the photograph was standing beside Richard Cole with one hand resting on a folder bearing my family's name.

May you like

And beneath the photograph, in Patricia's handwriting, were six words.

*He was the one who ordered it.*

Related Stories

Other posts