Amazed

Chapter 3: The Insurance Policy

I waited until Rebecca went upstairs before asking Sarah about the insurance policy.

I wanted Lily out of earshot. I wanted Margaret beside her. Most of all, I wanted a few minutes in which nobody said another impossible thing.

Margaret wheeled Lily toward the guest room, where the heating vent worked better than the one in the living room.

“Daddy?”” Lily called.

I crouched beside her.

“I'm right here.””

“Will Mommy stay tonight?””

I looked at Sarah.

Her eyes filled with tears.

“If you want me to, sweetheart,” she said.

Lily nodded fiercely.

“Forever.””

Sarah pressed her lips together, fighting to keep her voice steady.

“I'm going to try my hardest.””

When Margaret closed the guest-room door, Sarah and I stood alone in the living room.

For the first time, I noticed how thin she had become. Her hands trembled slightly. A small medical identification bracelet peeked from beneath her sleeve.

I reached for her fingers.

“Tell me about the policy.””

She looked down.

“After Lily was born, we took out a life insurance policy. You were the primary beneficiary on mine, and I was the primary beneficiary on yours.””

“That's right.””

“Rebecca knew about it.””

“Most of our friends knew. She was around us long before we married.””

Sarah pulled her hand away, not angrily but as though she needed space to think.

“Six weeks before the crash, I discovered someone had requested changes to the beneficiary information on my policy.””

I frowned.

“What changes?””

“Someone tried to replace you with another person.””

“Who?””

She shook her head.

“The paperwork was rejected because the signature didn't match. I confronted the insurance agent, but he couldn't tell me who submitted it. I assumed it was a clerical mistake.””

My stomach tightened.

“Why didn't you tell me?””

“Because I thought it was nothing. Then the accident happened.””

She walked toward the window.

Outside, the last light of evening stretched across the lawn. The oak tree Sarah had planted when Lily was born cast a long shadow over the grass.

“I started remembering things during rehabilitation,” she continued.

“Not everything. Just fragments. A red coat.

Headlights. A voice telling me I didn't understand what was happening.””

“Rebecca's voice?””

“I think so.””

I gripped the back of a chair.

“Why would she want your insurance money?””

“I don't know.””

The answer sounded honest, which somehow made it worse.

I had married Rebecca three months earlier. She had been patient with me after Sarah's presumed death. She'd attended Lily's school events, helped organize my business dinners, and never once complained when grief interrupted our plans.

But looking back, I could remember things I had dismissed.

Rebecca had insisted on handling the paperwork after Sarah's memorial.

She had asked questions about the insurance payout, though I'd assumed she was trying to help.

She had encouraged me to move Sarah's belongings into storage because Lily needed a fresh start.

And when I hesitated, Rebecca had placed both hands over mine and said, “You deserve to be happy again, Daniel.””

I had believed her.

“Did the insurance company pay out?”” Sarah asked.

I nodded slowly.

“The claim was approved eight months ago.””

Sarah closed her eyes.

“How much?””

“Two million dollars.””

She sat down abruptly.

“Daniel, I never wanted that money.””

“I know.””

“I wanted to come home.””

“I know.””

Her voice broke.

“Then why does everyone keep making me feel like I did something wrong by surviving?””

I knelt in front of her.

“You didn't.””

For a moment, she let me hold her hands.

Then a floorboard creaked above us.

We both looked up.

Rebecca stood halfway down the staircase, holding her phone.

“I heard enough,” she said.

I rose.

“Get your things.””

She descended the stairs slowly, dressed in a cream sweater and dark trousers. She had changed out of the clothes she'd worn earlier, as though a fresh outfit could erase what had happened in the kitchen.

“You're making a terrible mistake,” she said.

“Explain the insurance policy.””

She glanced at Sarah.

“I never changed anything.””

“You contacted the rehabilitation center,” Sarah replied.

“I called because Daniel was falling apart, and I thought someone might have information about what happened to you.””

“Under your maiden name?””

Rebecca's eyes narrowed.

“I was protecting my privacy.””

I almost laughed.

“From a hospital?””

She stepped closer to me.

“Daniel, please. Think about Lily. She's already confused. Bringing a woman into her life who claims to be her dead mother—”

“Claims?””

Sarah stood.

“Would you like me to tell him about the photograph?””

Rebecca froze.

I turned toward Sarah.

“What photograph?””

Sarah reached into her bag and took out a small envelope.

Inside was a photograph of a red sedan parked beside a rehabilitation center.

On the back, someone had written a date.

Three days before Sarah contacted her sister.

I stared at the image.

The car was unmistakable.

It belonged to Rebecca.

“How did you get this?”” I asked.

“The center's security guard remembered seeing the car several times. He saved a still image because the driver had asked staff whether I was expected to recover.””

Rebecca shook her head.

“That proves nothing.””

Sarah studied her.

“You came to see me.””

“No.””

“You stood outside my room.””

“No!””

“You told the receptionist you were a family friend.””

Rebecca's face had gone white.

I felt a coldness spread through me that no amount of anger could explain.

“Were you waiting for her to die?”” I asked.

Rebecca stared at me.

Then her expression changed.

The helpless wife vanished. In her place stood the woman who had poured ice water over my six-year-old daughter and demanded obedience.

“You have no idea what I've sacrificed for this family,” she said.

“You've sacrificed nothing for my family.””

“I gave you a chance to live again.””

“You threatened my daughter.””

“Because she refuses to accept me!””

“She is six years old!””

Rebecca's hand struck the staircase railing.

“She should have been grateful I stayed.””

Silence followed.

Even Rebecca seemed startled by her own words.

Sarah took a step toward her.

“You never wanted to be Lily's mother. You wanted my place.””

Rebecca's eyes flashed.

“Your place?”” She laughed bitterly.

“You were gone. Everyone was ready to move on. You had your funeral, your memorial, your photograph on the mantel. I did everything right, and you still came back.””

“Because I'm alive.””

“And you ruined everything.””

I moved between them.

“That's enough. You're leaving.””

Rebecca's phone buzzed.

She glanced at the screen, and for the first time that evening, genuine fear crossed her face.

She silenced it quickly.

But not before I saw the message preview.

*The second transfer is complete. Delete the old account before he checks it.*

I held out my hand.

“Give me the phone.””

Rebecca clutched it to her chest.

“No.””

“Who sent that message?””

She backed toward the stairs.

“It's none of your business.””

I stepped closer.

“It's about money taken from an insurance policy connected to my dead wife. I think it is very much my business.””

Her eyes flicked toward Sarah.

Then toward the front door.

May you like

And suddenly I understood.

Rebecca hadn't been acting alone.

Related Stories

Other posts