Amazed

Chapter 8: The Child Behind the Forgery

The following morning, Lily sat between Nathan and me in a small interview room at the police station.

She was eating strawberry yogurt and drawing pictures with a box of colored pencils.

I watched her carefully.

Every little movement felt precious.

The way she wrinkled her nose when she concentrated.

The way she tucked her hair behind her ear.

The way she hummed when she colored.

I had missed five years of these ordinary miracles.

Nathan was speaking with a family services representative outside.

Detective Vance entered carrying a thick folder.

“Caroline, we found something.””

I looked up.

“What?””

He placed a photograph on the table.

It showed two newborn babies in hospital bassinets.

Both had tiny identification bracelets.

I recognized Lily's bracelet immediately.

The other belonged to a baby named Amelia Carter.

“Who's Amelia?””

Vance sat down.

“According to the original hospital records, she was born eleven minutes after Lily.””

I looked at the photograph again.

“Were they twins?””

“No. Different mothers.””

He opened the folder.

“Both mothers were treated at St. Agnes on the night of the fire. There was a temporary evacuation after smoke entered the maternity wing.””

I felt cold.

“Go on.””

“During the evacuation, two newborn identification bracelets were switched.””

I stared at him.

“By accident?””

“That was the original explanation.””

He showed me a copy of the hospital incident report.

A nurse had reported the discrepancy the next morning.

But the report had been removed from the official record.

“Who removed it?””

“Richard Hale requested the file through a legal authorization.””

I shook my head.

“Why would he care about another baby?””

Vance opened another document.

“Because Amelia Carter's biological mother was a woman named Victoria Whitmore.””

I looked at Nathan.

He had just entered the room.

He stopped when he heard the name.

“My aunt?””

Vance nodded.

“Your father's younger sister.””

Nathan pulled out a chair.

“Victoria died in a car accident when I was twenty. She had a baby?””

“According to these records, yes.””

Nathan stared at the photograph.

“Why didn't anyone tell us?””

“Because the child was placed under a different identity.””

I looked at Detective Vance.

“Are you saying Juliette may have raised Amelia instead of Lily?””

“That's one possibility.””

My stomach twisted.

“Then where is Lily?””

Vance turned another page.

“The original hospital bracelet records show that the child who left St. Agnes with Juliette was identified as Amelia Carter.””

I felt my breath catch.

“Where did the real Lily go?””

“That's what we're trying to establish.””

Nathan leaned forward.

“Could she have been adopted by another family?””

“Yes.””

“Could she be alive?””

Vance nodded.

“Absolutely.””

For a moment, hope and terror collided inside my chest.

My daughter might have spent five years somewhere else.

Perhaps she had a family.

Perhaps she had another name.

Perhaps she had been loved.

But I couldn't stop thinking about the little girl in the lake house.

The child who had called Juliette Mommy.

If she wasn't my biological daughter, what would happen to her?

I looked through the glass partition.

Lily was drawing two adults holding hands beneath a yellow sun.

“Detective,” I whispered, “does she know?””

“Not yet.””

“Don't tell her until we understand everything.””

Vance nodded.

Then he removed another photograph from the folder.

It showed Juliette leaving a hospital five years earlier.

She was carrying a baby wrapped in a pink blanket.

But there was something strange.

The woman walking beside her was our family attorney's assistant, Margaret Ellis.

I recognized her immediately.

“Margaret helped me when I was recovering.””

Vance nodded.

“She gave us the information about the adoption.””

“Then why is she with Juliette?””

He turned the photograph over.

There was a handwritten note.

One child delivered. Second payment pending.

I felt sick.

“Margaret was involved?””

“We believe she was pressured into participating.””

Nathan shook his head.

“Who paid her?””

Vance looked at the next page.

A bank account.

A wire transfer.

The name attached to it was unmistakable.

Nathan Whitmore.

He went completely still.

“That isn't possible.””

I stared at him.

“Did you send money to Margaret?””

“No.””

“Did anyone have access to your accounts?””

He rubbed his forehead.

“My father handled the family finances after Victoria died.””

Detective Vance leaned forward.

“Your father's company made several payments to Richard Hale during the months following the fire.””

Nathan stared at the document.

“My father died three years ago.””

I felt a terrible suspicion forming.

“What if he knew about the children?””

Nathan looked at me.

“Why would he?””

Vance closed the folder.

“Because Victoria's estate contained a trust for her biological child. Whoever controlled that child controlled nearly $12 million.””

Silence filled the room.

I looked through the glass at Lily.

She was holding up her drawing.

Two adults.

A little girl.

And a fourth person standing far away.

I approached the glass.

“Who's that?”” I asked.

Lily pointed to the distant figure.

“That's my other mommy.””

My throat tightened.

“Your other mommy?””

She nodded.

“Grandpa said I had another mommy before Juliette.””

I turned toward Detective Vance.

He looked as shocked as I felt.

Lily reached into her backpack and pulled out a folded photograph.

It showed a woman with dark hair holding a newborn baby.

On the back, someone had written a name.

Victoria Whitmore.

May you like

And beneath it were six words.

If you find her, tell her everything.

Related Stories

Other posts