Chapter 5: The Visitor Who Knew Sarah Was Alive

Nobody moved for several seconds.
I held Lily's shoulders gently.
“Sweetheart, what lady?””
“The lady with the red shoes.””
Vanessa's face drained of color.
Richard immediately opened his briefcase.
“Describe her.””
Lily looked at the ceiling, thinking.
“She had short hair. She smelled like flowers. She came when Daddy was at work.””
I glanced at Vanessa.
“Did you let her inside?””
Vanessa shook her head.
“No.””
Lily interrupted.
“Yes, you did.””
Vanessa turned sharply.
“Lily, stop talking.””
My daughter flinched.
I stepped between them.
“Don't you ever speak to her like that again.””
Lily moved closer to me.
“She went into your office,” she whispered.
“And Vanessa gave her the blue folder.””
My blood ran cold.
The blue folder.
The one Lily had mentioned earlier.
The one containing my business documents.
Richard looked at me.
“Have you checked whether anything is missing?””
“No.””
“We need to leave immediately.””
I turned to my mother.
“Take Lily home with you.””
Lily grabbed my sleeve.
“No, Daddy!””
I knelt.
“I need you to go with Grandma for a little while.””
“Are you going to leave me?””
The question nearly destroyed me.
I remembered the slap.
The sound.
Her little hand against her cheek.
I brushed her hair away from her forehead.
“Never. I'm not leaving you. I promise.””
She looked at me.
“You believed Vanessa.””
I swallowed.
“I know.””
“You didn't believe me.””
My eyes burned.
“You were right, sweetheart. I was wrong.””
Lily touched her cheek.
I wanted to disappear.
My mother gently pulled her close.
“I'll stay with her,” Margaret said.
“You find out what's happening.””
I nodded.
Richard arranged for the other attorney to accompany them while he and I headed toward my house.
Vanessa was taken aside by two security officers from the church.
Before they led her away, she looked at me.
“Michael, you don't understand. Sarah is worse than you think.””
I didn't respond.
She leaned closer.
“Ask her what happened to the real baby.””
Then the officers escorted her outside.
The drive home took twenty-three minutes.
I barely spoke.
Richard sat beside me, reviewing documents.
At a red light, he finally looked up.
“There's something I haven't told you.””
I kept my eyes on the road.
“What?””
“Sarah contacted my office six weeks ago.””
My hands tightened around the steering wheel.
“She contacted you?””
“Yes.””
“Why didn't you tell me?””
“Because she specifically asked me not to.””
I laughed without humor.
“Apparently, everyone has been making decisions about my family without telling me.””
Richard looked uncomfortable.
“She said she needed time to confirm something.””
“Confirm what?””
He hesitated.
“Whether the boy in the photograph was actually your son.””
I slammed on the brakes.
A car behind us honked.
I turned toward him.
“What boy?””
“The newborn.””
I pulled into a gas station parking lot.
“Explain.””
Richard removed the photograph from his briefcase.
“Sarah believed she had given birth shortly before the accident.””
I stared at him.
“That's impossible. Sarah wasn't pregnant when she died.””
“According to the official records, she wasn't.””
“But this photograph…”
“Was taken at a private medical facility. Sarah's name appears on the birth paperwork.””
I felt dizzy.
“Are you telling me I have a son?””
“I'm telling you the possibility is serious enough to investigate.””
I looked at the photograph again.
A tiny baby.
Dark hair.
A hospital bracelet with my surname.
I remembered Sarah's final months.
The way she'd become withdrawn.
The doctor's appointments she'd attended alone.
The arguments we'd had because she refused to tell me what was wrong.
I'd assumed it was depression.
Now every memory felt different.
We reached my house just after three.
The front door was unlocked.
I immediately noticed the hallway light was on.
I knew I'd switched it off before leaving that morning.
Richard raised one hand.
“Don't go inside yet.””
He called the police.
While we waited, I walked around the side of the house.
The nursery window was open.
A white curtain moved gently in the afternoon breeze.
My stomach tightened.
Through the glass, I could see the rocking chair.
Sarah's rocking chair.
And something sitting on it.
A small red shoe.
The same kind Lily had described.
When the officers arrived, they entered the house first.
They found no one.
But my office had been ransacked.
Drawers were open. Papers were scattered across the carpet. The safe behind my bookshelf stood open.
The blue folder was gone.
Richard examined the room.
“Whoever came here knew exactly what they wanted.””
I walked toward the nursery.
The door creaked.
Everything looked the same as it had four years earlier.
The little wooden mobile.
The faded pink blanket.
The rocking chair.
Except the floorboards beneath the old crib had been disturbed.
I knelt.
One of the officers brought a flashlight.
“There's something underneath,” he said.
Together, we lifted the loose wooden panel.
Beneath it was a metal box.
Inside were several photographs, a small digital recorder, and a sealed envelope.
The first photograph showed Sarah holding a newborn baby.
The second showed Vanessa standing outside a hospital.
The third showed a woman I had never seen before.
She wore red shoes.
I turned the photograph over.
Written on the back were five words:
The woman who raised Sarah.
Richard went pale.
“Michael…”
“What?””
He pointed to the final photograph.
It showed the same woman standing beside an older man.
My father-in-law.
James.
I stared at the picture.
“Who is she?””
Richard slowly took the photograph from me.
“That's Eleanor Anderson.””
I frowned.
“Who?””
He looked directly into my eyes.
“Your biological mother.””
I felt the air leave my lungs.
“My mother is Margaret.””
Richard shook his head.
“Margaret raised you. But Eleanor was the woman who gave birth to you.””
I stared at him.
“Why would my biological mother be involved in Sarah's disappearance?””
He opened the envelope.
Inside was a handwritten note.
Michael, if you're reading this, Vanessa has failed to find the evidence. But don't trust the woman you call Mother.
I read it again.
Then I heard my phone ring.
It was Margaret.
I answered immediately.
“Mom? Is Lily okay?””
Her voice was shaking.
“Michael, listen to me. You need to come back to the church.””
“Why? What's wrong?””
“Lily remembered something.””
“What?””
My mother began crying.
“Sarah didn't die four years ago. I helped her disappear.””
I stopped breathing.
Then she whispered the words that shattered everything I thought I knew.
“And the woman who called you from that phone today…”
May you like
She paused.
“Wasn't Sarah.””