Chapter 3: The Truth About Sophie's Mother

I couldn't move.
The DNA report showed a parentage probability of 0.00%.
I read it again.
Then a third time.
"That's impossible," I whispered.
Detective Mitchell folded her hands.
"This document appears to be a private laboratory report. We haven't independently verified it.""
"Sophie is my daughter.""
"I understand.""
"No. You don't understand. I raised her.
I was there when she took her first steps. I held her when she had nightmares. I buried her mother.""
My voice broke.
"She is my daughter.""
Detective Mitchell nodded.
"Nothing in this report changes the fact that you've been her father.""
I looked away.
The room seemed smaller.
Sophie's biological mother, Emily Carter, had died in a car accident three years earlier.
I'd met Emily when we were both in college. We dated for several years, married young, and had Sophie shortly afterward.
Our marriage hadn't been perfect.
But I had loved her.
After Emily's death, I had struggled to raise Sophie alone while managing my construction company.
Vanessa entered our lives almost a year later.
She seemed kind.
She brought Sophie toys, read bedtime stories, and never complained when my daughter climbed into our bed after a nightmare.
When she asked me to marry her, she promised she'd never make Sophie feel like an outsider.
I believed every word.
Now I was staring at a document suggesting my entire understanding of my daughter's birth was wrong.
Detective Mitchell slid another paper across the table.
It was a copy of an old medical record.
Emily had apparently requested additional testing during her pregnancy.
The document contained a handwritten note:
Possible paternity discrepancy. Follow-up recommended.
"Did Emily ever tell you she suspected you weren't Sophie's biological father?"" the detective asked.
"No.""
"Did you two have any serious relationship problems before her death?""
I rubbed my forehead.
"We had an argument about Vanessa.""
Detective Mitchell looked up.
"Vanessa?""
"Emily knew her before I did. They weren't friends, exactly. Vanessa worked with her at a marketing firm.""
"Did Emily ever explain why she was concerned?""
I shook my head.
"She said Vanessa was dangerous. I thought she was jealous because Vanessa and I had become friends.""
Detective Mitchell went still.
"Do you remember anything else she said?""
I closed my eyes.
Suddenly, I remembered an evening shortly before Emily died.
She had been standing in our bedroom, holding Sophie.
"Michael, promise me something.""
"What, honey?""
"If anything happens to me, don't let Vanessa raise our daughter.""
I had laughed nervously.
"Why would you say something like that?""
Emily had looked toward the hallway.
"Because she knows things about this family that you don't.""
I'd been annoyed.
I thought grief, stress, and motherhood were making her paranoid.
Two weeks later, she died.
The police report said her car had crossed the center line during heavy rain.
No other vehicle was identified.
I had accepted it.
Now I wasn't so sure.
Detective Mitchell opened another document.
"This is an email your mother sent to herself approximately six weeks before she disappeared.""
The message contained only a few lines.
Daniel was with Emily the night before the accident. Vanessa knows. I found the original photographs. The truth is in the storage unit.
I felt the blood drain from my face.
"Daniel knew Emily?""
"Apparently.""
"How?""
Detective Mitchell searched the records.
"According to an old employment file, Daniel and Emily worked for the same company before he married Vanessa.""
I stood up.
"This is insane.""
"Sit down, Mr. Bennett.""
"Was Daniel involved in Emily's death?""
"We don't know yet.""
"Then find out!""
"We're trying.""
My phone vibrated.
A message appeared from an unknown number.
Stop digging into the past. Sophie deserves a peaceful life.
I showed Detective Mitchell.
She photographed the screen.
"Don't respond.""
Another message arrived.
This time it contained a photograph.
Sophie was sitting at our kitchen table.
The picture had been taken from inside the house.
My daughter was alone.
I felt my legs weaken.
"When was this taken?""
The detective examined the image.
"Recently.""
"Someone was inside my house.""
She immediately called an officer.
I called the temporary caregiver assigned to Sophie.
She answered after two rings.
"Mr. Bennett?""
"Is Sophie with you?""
"Yes. She's sleeping.""
"Is anyone else there?""
"Just me.""
I exhaled.
Then the caregiver said something that made me freeze.
"Although, Mr. Bennett, someone called earlier claiming to be Sophie's aunt. She said you had authorized her to pick Sophie up.""
"What?""
"She knew Sophie's full name and birthday. I refused because you hadn't given me permission.""
"Did she give you a name?""
"She said her name was Emily.""
I gripped the phone.
Emily was dead.
Or at least, that was what I'd believed for three years.
Detective Mitchell took the phone from my hand.
"Ma'am, don't let anyone near that child. We're sending officers to your location.""
Then she looked at me.
"Mr. Bennett, we need to consider the possibility that someone has been using Emily's identity.""
I stared at the DNA report.
At the message.
At the photograph of my daughter.
And suddenly, I understood something.
Vanessa hadn't simply wanted to punish Sophie.
May you like
She had wanted to make sure my daughter stayed silent.
Because Sophie might be the only person left who knew what really happened the night her mother died.