Chapter 6: The Father Sarah Never Told Me About

I read the final sentence of Sarah's letter until the words began to blur.
*Do not let Lily meet her biological father.*
I looked at the little girl sleeping beside me.
My daughter.
The child I had raised since the day she was born.
The child whose first steps I had celebrated, whose nightmares I had comforted, whose tiny hand I had held at her mother's funeral.
I read the sentence again.
Then I noticed something beneath Sarah's signature.
A date.
Three days before the accident.
My phone rang.
Patricia.
"Michael, did you find anything?""
I hesitated.
"Sarah left me a letter.""
"What does it say?""
"She says Lily's biological father is someone I know.""
Silence.
Then Patricia whispered, "Oh, Michael.""
"Who is he?""
"I think you already know.""
I stood up.
"Tell me.""
"Your older brother.""
I nearly dropped the phone.
My brother, Andrew Carter, was forty-two. He lived in Raleigh and owned a successful construction company. He had been my best man when I married Sarah.
He had carried Lily around the hospital nursery.
He had stood beside me at Sarah's funeral.
He had even helped me pay some of the medical bills after the accident.
"That's impossible," I said.
Patricia sighed.
"Sarah told me she had been seeing Andrew before you married her. She said it was over long before Lily was born, but Andrew never accepted it.""
I pressed my hand against the wall.
"Why would she marry me if she was carrying his child?""
"Because she loved you, Michael. And because Andrew had promised to stay away.""
I looked at the photograph inside the music box.
Sarah was holding newborn Lily.
On the back, she had written:
My little miracle. No matter what anyone says, you are loved.
I called Andrew.
He answered on the fourth ring.
"Hey, little brother. Everything okay?""
"Where are you?""
"At the office. Why?""
"I need to ask you something.""
He laughed.
"That sounds serious.""
"Was Lily your daughter?""
The silence was immediate.
Then Andrew exhaled.
"Where did you hear that?""
My stomach dropped.
"Answer me.""
"Michael, this isn't a conversation for the phone.""
"Was she yours?""
He finally said, "Yes.""
I closed my eyes.
Two years of memories suddenly rearranged themselves.
Andrew insisting on holding Lily at family gatherings.
Andrew paying for her birthday parties.
Andrew visiting us more frequently after Sarah died.
I had thought he was simply being a good uncle.
"You knew?"" I whispered.
"Sarah told me before the wedding.""
"And you let me raise her without telling me?""
Andrew's voice hardened.
"Sarah made that decision. She wanted you to be her father.""
"Why did she write that I should never let Lily meet you?""
"Because she was afraid.""
"Of what?""
"Of what I might do if I lost her.""
My grip tightened around the phone.
"What did you do to Sarah?""
"Nothing.""
"Then why is your name in her letter?""
Andrew sighed.
"Michael, you're getting involved in something you don't understand. Vanessa was supposed to handle this quietly.""
My blood turned cold.
"What did you just say?""
He went silent.
I repeated the question.
"What does Vanessa have to do with you?""
Andrew lowered his voice.
"Listen carefully. Sarah left something behind that belongs to me. I want it returned.""
"You're talking about the USB drive?""
Another silence.
Then he said, "You found it.""
I looked at the little music box.
"How do you know about that?""
"Because Sarah stole documents from my company.""
I almost laughed.
"Your company?""
"She had information that could destroy my business.""
"What information?""
"Michael, give me the drive. I'll give you enough money to start a new life somewhere else. You and Lily can forget all of this.""
I felt sick.
"You think I would sell my daughter?""
"I think you should consider what happens when powerful people get involved.""
The call ended.
I immediately copied the USB drive onto my laptop.
There were dozens of files.
Bank statements.
Photographs.
Vehicle registrations.
And several audio recordings.
One file was labeled:
*ANDREW — ORIGINAL AGREEMENT.*
I clicked it.
Sarah's voice filled the room.
"Andrew, I have the documents. You can't keep doing this.""
Andrew answered.
"You have no idea how much money is involved.""
"People are getting hurt.""
"Then stop asking questions.""
"You're using Daniel to move stolen vehicles and falsify accident reports.""
"Keep your voice down.""
"I won't.""
Then came a sound.
A chair scraping.
Andrew's voice became frighteningly calm.
"If you go to the police, you will lose everything. Michael will lose his job. Lily will grow up without either parent.""
Sarah began crying.
"She's your daughter, Andrew.""
"I know exactly who she is.""
The recording ended.
I sat motionless.
Then another file appeared on the screen.
A video.
It showed Vanessa sitting in a restaurant across from Andrew.
The date was six months earlier.
The same month I married her.
Andrew placed a folder on the table.
Vanessa opened it.
"How long do you think this will take?"" she asked.
Andrew smiled.
"Once Michael signs the guardianship documents, we'll have everything.""
"And the little girl?""
Andrew leaned closer.
"She'll be sent somewhere she can't interfere.""
Vanessa looked down at the folder.
"And Sarah's box?""
"Get it before Michael discovers the letter.""
The video ended.
My phone buzzed.
A message from Andrew.
*I know where you're going tomorrow. Don't go to storage unit 214.*
Then another message appeared.
*And Michael? Don't make me choose between my brother and my daughter.*
I stared at the screen.
For the first time in my life, I understood something terrifying.
May you like
Andrew didn't want to be Lily's father.
He wanted to own her.