Chapter 7: Olivia's Evidence
The Chicago Cultural Center was crowded with tourists when I arrived the next morning.
Sunlight spilled through the windows, illuminating the marble floors and the intricate ceiling above the central hall. People wandered past with cameras and coffee cups, unaware that I was about to meet the sister my husband had hidden from me.
Margaret waited at a nearby table, dressed in a charcoal suit, with a newspaper open in front of her.
She gave me a small nod.
"Your father wanted to come," she said.
"I know.""
"He agreed to wait at the office, but he's expecting us to check in afterward.""
"That's fair.""
I ordered coffee I didn't want and chose a table near the windows.
At ten past ten, a woman in a green coat approached.
Her face was paler than it had appeared in the wedding photograph. She carried a canvas bag and kept looking over her shoulder.
"Claire?""
I stood.
"Olivia?""
She nodded, then looked at Margaret.
"I thought you were coming alone.""
"I'm here to listen," Margaret said.
"I won't interfere unless Claire asks me to.""
Olivia hesitated before sitting.
"I shouldn't have messaged you.""
"Then why did you?""
She looked at me for a long moment.
"Because I watched my brother marry you, and I knew what my father wanted from that marriage. When I saw you leave with your father last night, I realized things had gone further than I expected.""
"You were at my wedding. Why didn't you tell me then?""
"Because I was afraid.""
"Of Ethan?""
"Of both of them.""
She opened her bag and removed a small photograph.
It showed Ethan standing beside a blonde woman in a white dress. They were in front of a restaurant, and his arm was wrapped around her waist.
"This is Natalie," Olivia said.
"Three years ago, she was supposed to become my sister-in-law.""
I studied the photograph.
"Did Ethan love her?""
Olivia let out a humorless laugh.
"He told everyone he did.""
"That's not what I asked.""
She looked down.
"I think he loved how much she trusted him.""
The words landed painfully.
Olivia continued.
"Natalie's father owned a construction supply company. It wasn't enormous, but it had valuable contracts and a solid credit history. My father wanted access to those relationships. He told Natalie that the two families could build something together.""
"Like my father and Richard.""
"Exactly.""
"What happened?""
Olivia wrapped both hands around her coffee cup.
"Natalie was smart. She worked in accounting, and she started asking questions about some invoices connected to my father's company. She found payments that didn't match the contracts. When she asked Ethan about them, he said she was misunderstanding ordinary business expenses.""
"Did she believe him?""
"At first. Then she found more discrepancies.""
Olivia reached into her bag again and removed a folded sheet of paper.
"This is a copy of an email she sent me before she left.""
I read it.
Natalie's message was brief.
*Olivia, I know you think I'm imagining things, but I found a document with my name on it. It says I approved a financial arrangement I never saw. Ethan says it's a formality.
Your father says I should trust him. I'm going to ask for the original.*
My fingers tightened around the paper.
"Did she ever get it?""
"No. Two days later, the engagement was called off.""
"Who ended it?""
"According to my father, Natalie was emotionally unstable and decided to leave Ethan. According to Natalie, Ethan threatened to expose private information about her family if she continued asking questions.""
"What private information?""
Olivia shook her head.
"I don't know. She never told me everything.""
"Did you believe her?""
"Not at first."" Olivia's eyes filled with tears.
"I was younger, and my father told me Natalie was trying to destroy Ethan's future. I repeated things I shouldn't have repeated. I helped make her sound unreliable.""
She looked at me.
"I've regretted that ever since.""
For a moment, neither of us spoke.
Then I asked the question that had been pressing against my ribs since I read her first message.
"Why did Ethan tell me he was an only child?""
Olivia looked toward the entrance.
"Because I refused to help my father with the business after Natalie left. I moved out. My father told people I was studying overseas, and Ethan agreed to stop mentioning me. It was easier for them to pretend I didn't exist.""
"But you came to my wedding.""
"My father invited me because he wanted to demonstrate that the family was united. He told me to stay quiet and behave.""
I remembered the woman in the green dress watching Ethan.
"What did you see last night?""
"I saw my brother throw a towel at you.""
Her voice broke.
"I wanted to walk over and take your hand. But I froze. Then your father arrived, and I saw the look on Ethan's face. I realized that if I stayed silent again, I would be helping them do to you what they tried to do to Natalie.""
Margaret leaned forward.
"Olivia, do you have any original records from that period? Emails, contracts, correspondence?""
Olivia nodded.
"I kept copies of some things. Not everything. But I have a scanned agreement Natalie gave me before she left.""
She removed a flash drive from her bag.
"I've never given this to my father.""
Margaret did not take it immediately.
"Where did you obtain these files?""
"Natalie sent them to me. Some are copies of documents she received from Ethan. Others are emails between Ethan and my father that were accidentally forwarded to me.""
"Have they been altered?""
"Not by me.""
Margaret took the drive and placed it in a small evidence envelope from her briefcase.
"We'll need to preserve the files and verify their origins before relying on them.""
Olivia nodded.
Then she turned toward me.
"There is something else.""
I waited.
"After Natalie left, my father tried to arrange another engagement for Ethan. It didn't work. The next woman he pursued was you.""
I felt my stomach tighten.
"How did he know about me?""
"Through a charity event. Your father had donated money to a foundation my father wanted access to. Ethan saw your photograph in an event program. He asked about you.""
I remembered our first meeting at that charity gala.
Ethan had approached me with two glasses of sparkling water because he had noticed I wasn't drinking alcohol. He'd made me laugh by pretending he couldn't remember the name of the famous architect standing beside us.
It had felt spontaneous.
It had felt like the beginning of a love story.
"Did he start dating me because of my father?""
Olivia looked miserable.
"I can't prove what he felt. But my father began talking about the Bennett family before Ethan asked you out.""
I turned toward the window.
Outside, a bus groaned to a stop. A cyclist swerved around a delivery truck. Life continued, indifferent to the fact that the memories I treasured were being rearranged into something uglier.
Margaret spoke gently.
"Claire, we should review the files before drawing conclusions.""
I nodded.
Olivia reached across the table, stopping short of touching my hand.
"I am sorry.""
I looked at her.
"For what?""
"For watching you marry him without warning you.""
I believed her regret.
But I wasn't ready to forgive her.
"Thank you for telling me," I said.
"I need time.""
She nodded.
"I understand.""
As she stood to leave, she hesitated.
"Claire, there's one file you need to look at first. It's called Wedding Conditions. I didn't understand it when Natalie sent it to me. But after seeing your name on that agreement, I think I finally do.""
Margaret's expression sharpened.
"Where is it?""
"On the drive.""
Olivia pulled on her coat.
Then she looked at me one last time.
"Please don't let Ethan convince you that you imagined what happened last night. He did the same thing to Natalie. He made her question everything she remembered.""
She walked toward the exit.
I watched her disappear into the crowd.
Margaret placed the evidence envelope in her briefcase.
"We'll review the files with our forensic team.""
"How long will that take?""
"We can begin today.""
My phone vibrated.
A message from Ethan.
*My father has asked me to attend a family meeting tonight. He says you need to be there. Apparently, your father is threatening to destroy our families over a misunderstanding.*
I read it twice.
Then another message arrived.
*Come tonight, Claire. If you still care about our marriage, you'll hear everyone out.*
I showed Margaret.
She studied the screen.
"Do you want to go?""
I looked down at my coffee.
"No.""
May you like
Then I looked back at the message.
"But I want to know what they're planning.""