Chapter 1: The Woman He Should Have Recognized
The police officer slapped me in front of forty witnesses, reached for his handcuffs, and announced that I was going to jail. Three seconds later, my bailiff called me by a title that made the entire courthouse hallway fall silent.
But the officer still didn't release my arm.
The judicial elevator was out of service that morning, so I entered the Davidson County Courthouse in Nashville through the public lobby, carrying a charcoal briefcase stuffed with trial notes, exhibits, and a folder I had spent half the night reviewing.
My black judicial robe was hanging upstairs in my chambers.
At forty-three, I had learned that people treated a woman differently depending on what she wore. In my robe, strangers called me Your Honor before I spoke. In a plain suit, some assumed I was a secretary who had wandered into the wrong hallway.
That morning, I was about to discover how dangerous that assumption could become.
I had barely reached the elevators when a uniformed officer stepped directly into my path.
"Courtroom 4B is the other way, Sarah.""
I stopped.
"My name isn't Sarah.""
Officer Derek Harlan glanced at my briefcase, then at the stack of files in my arms.
"Save it for the judge.""
"I intend to.""
He gave a short, humorless laugh.
"People like you always think they're smarter than everybody else.""
I could have walked around him. I could have shown him my identification immediately. I could even have called my courtroom clerk and asked her to confirm my arrival.
Instead, I made the mistake of assuming that a simple misunderstanding could be resolved with a simple explanation.
"Officer, I'm expected upstairs. Please let me through.""
Harlan shifted to block me again.
"Identification.""
"Certainly.""
I reached toward my purse.
His hand closed around my wrist.
"Don't reach for anything.""
I froze.
"Officer, take your hand off me.""
"You're being detained.""
"On what grounds?""
"Suspicious behavior. Refusal to follow instructions.""
I looked down at his fingers digging into my skin.
"I have identified myself as a judicial officer. My credentials are in my purse, and I am willing to show them to you.""
"You're not a judicial officer.""
"You don't know who I am.""
"I know exactly what you're doing.""
A woman waiting near the elevators turned toward us. She wore a navy cardigan and carried a paper coffee cup. Her eyes moved from Harlan's grip to my face.
"Excuse me," she said.
"She was just trying to get to the elevator.""
Harlan didn't even look at her.
"Ma'am, stay out of this.""
The woman took one step backward, but she didn't leave.
I tried to pull my wrist free.
Harlan tightened his grip.
"Now you're resisting.""
"No. I'm asking you to release me.""
"You're under detention.""
"For what offense?""
"Obstruction.""
"Then call your supervisor.""
His jaw tightened.
"Don't tell me how to do my job.""
I could hear the courtroom doors opening and closing behind us. Attorneys moved through the corridor. A clerk pushed a cart stacked with banker boxes. Somewhere down the hall, a phone rang repeatedly.
Ordinary courthouse sounds.
Then Harlan raised his voice.
"Put your hands where I can see them!""
"They are where you can see them.""
"Stop arguing!""
"I'm not arguing. I'm asking you to follow the law.""
He struck me before I could say another word.
The sound cracked against the marble walls.
My head snapped sideways. Pain flared across my cheek, and my briefcase slipped from my fingers, hitting the floor hard enough to send documents skidding beneath people's shoes.
For a moment, the hallway seemed to lose its sound.
I touched my mouth.
When I pulled my fingers away, there was blood on them.
The woman in the navy cardigan gasped.
"Oh my God. He hit her.""
Harlan released my wrist only long enough to reach for his handcuffs.
"Now you're getting charged with resisting and assaulting an officer.""
I stared at him.
He had hit me. I had not touched him. And somehow, in his mind, he was already the victim.
"Officer Harlan," I said carefully, reading the nameplate on his chest, "I am ordering you to step back and contact your supervisor.""
His eyes narrowed.
"You don't get to order me around.""
"Call your supervisor.""
"Why? So you can tell him you're the governor, too?""
Someone near the elevators whispered, "This is unbelievable.""
Another person began recording.
Harlan noticed the phones.
"Put those away! This is an active law enforcement matter!""
The woman in the cardigan raised hers higher.
"You slapped her in the face. I'm not putting anything away.""
Harlan turned back to me and pulled one cuff free.
"Turn around.""
I kept my hands visible.
"No.""
His expression hardened.
"What did you say?""
"I said no. You have no lawful basis to arrest me, and I will not participate in a false account of what happened.""
He seized my upper arm again.
"You're making this worse for yourself.""
A familiar voice thundered from the far end of the corridor.
"Officer! Take your hands off her!""
I recognized the voice before I saw the man.
Marcus Reed, my courtroom bailiff, came pushing through the gathering crowd. He was a broad-shouldered former Marine who had served the courthouse for eleven years. I had watched him calm angry defendants, separate fighting attorneys, and escort grieving families from courtrooms with a kindness that never appeared in his official job description.
Now his face was pale with anger.
He reached us and looked first at Harlan's grip, then at the blood on my mouth.
"Your Honor," Marcus said, his voice suddenly breaking, "are you hurt?""
The hallway went silent.
Harlan's fingers loosened.
But he still didn't let go.
Behind him, the doors to Courtroom 4B swung open.
District Attorney Elaine Porter stepped into the corridor beside defense attorney Michael Grant. Behind them came the twelve jurors from the trial I had presided over the previous afternoon.
Every one of them recognized me.
Elaine's mouth fell open.
Michael stopped so abruptly that the juror behind him nearly collided with his back.
And Harlan, still holding my arm, looked from Marcus to the attorneys, then to the jurors.
He gave an uneasy laugh.
"Wait a minute. What's going on here?""
Marcus stepped between us.
"Release her. Now.""
Harlan finally let go.
I straightened my jacket, ignoring the sting across my cheek.
Then I looked him directly in the eyes.
"My name is Judge Elizabeth Bennett. I preside over Courtroom 4B.""
His handcuffs slipped from his fingers and struck the marble floor.
May you like
But before anyone could speak, Elaine Porter looked toward the courtroom doors and said the one thing that made Harlan's face turn completely white.
"Someone needs to secure that courtroom. Judge Bennett was about to hear the case involving Officer Harlan's own police department.""