Chapter 2: The Secret Behind the Accident

I wanted to believe there was an explanation.
I wanted Rebecca to laugh, shake her head, and tell me Sarah was confused.
But Rebecca didn't laugh.
She stared at the photograph as though it were a loaded weapon.
“Daniel, this is insane,” she said.
Sarah folded her hands.
“Then explain the hospital records.””
Rebecca looked at me.
“She's been missing for two years. You have no idea what happened to her. You can't just believe everything she says.””
“I haven't believed anything yet,” I replied.
Sarah reached into her bag again.
This time, she pulled out a plastic folder containing several documents.
“I was found near the Harpeth River,” she explained.
“My car went over the embankment, but I managed to escape before it sank. I was unconscious when someone found me.””
I sat down slowly.
“They took me to a rehabilitation facility. I had a head injury, and I couldn't remember my name. I didn't even know I had a daughter.””
Margaret covered her mouth.
Sarah continued.
“I spent months learning to walk properly again. I had no identification, no family records, and no memory of where I belonged.””
“Why didn't the hospital find us?”” I asked.
“They tried.””
She looked at me.
“Someone called the facility and told them I was a woman named Elizabeth Carter. They claimed my family had been notified and didn't want contact.””
My hands tightened around the chair.
“Who?””
Sarah turned a page.
“Rebecca.””
Rebecca slammed her phone onto the counter.
“You have no proof!””
Sarah calmly removed another sheet.
“There's a recorded call.””
Margaret leaned forward.
“Can we hear it?””
Sarah nodded.
She pressed play.
A woman's voice filled the kitchen.
It was unmistakably Rebecca's.
“She's confused. Her family doesn't want her back. If she asks about a husband or child, don't encourage those delusions. They were part of her old life.””
The recording ended.
Nobody spoke.
I turned toward Rebecca.
“Did you make that call?””
She shook her head immediately.
“That could be anyone.””
Sarah reached for another document.
“The number was registered to your old phone.””
Rebecca's face changed.
I remembered that phone.
She had told me it was stolen shortly after we started dating. She had even asked me to help replace it.
“Why?”” I asked.
Rebecca took a step toward me.
“Daniel, listen to me. When we met, you were broken. You barely slept.
You talked about Sarah every night. I was the person who helped you rebuild your life.””
“That's not an answer.””
“I loved you!””
“And you knew my wife was alive?””
Her eyes filled with tears.
“I knew she was dangerous.””
Sarah stiffened.
“Dangerous?””
Rebecca looked directly at her.
“You were unstable. You had a history of emotional problems. You drove off that road with a child waiting at home.””
“Stop,” I said.
But Rebecca continued.
“Daniel, you know how many times you told me you wished you could start over? I gave you that chance.””
Sarah stood.
“I was trying to get home to my daughter.””
Rebecca's expression hardened.
“You should have stayed dead.””
Margaret gasped.
I stepped between them.
“Get out.””
Rebecca stared at me.
“What?””
“Go upstairs. Pack a bag. You're leaving.””
She laughed bitterly.
“You can't throw me out because of some old recording.””
“I'm not throwing you out because of a recording. I'm throwing you out because you poured ice water over my six-year-old daughter and threatened her.””
Rebecca's eyes flashed.
“She needs discipline!””
“She needs a mother who doesn't frighten her.””
For a moment, Rebecca looked as though she might slap me.
Instead, she turned and walked upstairs.
Sarah sat down heavily.
I pulled out the chair beside her.
“Why didn't you contact me as soon as you remembered?””
Her eyes filled again.
“I tried.””
“What do you mean?””
She looked toward the staircase.
“Three weeks ago, I called your number. Rebecca answered.””
My stomach dropped.
“What did she say?””
Sarah's voice trembled.
“She told me Lily had died.””
I stared at her.
“She said there had been complications from Lily's condition. She told me you couldn't bear to speak about it.””
My throat tightened.
“She told you our daughter was dead?””
Sarah nodded.
“I almost stopped trying.””
Then Margaret reached across the table and took Sarah's hand.
“I knew something was wrong,” she whispered.
I turned toward her.
“What did you know?””
Margaret looked toward the staircase, then back at me.
“Mr. Daniel, there's something I've kept from you because I was afraid of losing my job.””
She pulled a small notebook from her apron pocket.
“I started writing down everything Rebecca said to Lily.””
She opened it to a page dated two weeks earlier.
At the bottom was a sentence written in shaky handwriting.
Rebecca said Sarah wasn't the only woman who could disappear from this house.
My blood ran cold.
May you like
Because beneath that sentence was another name.
Margaret's.