Chapter 8: The Original File

The young man stepped out of Thomas's car.
He looked about twenty-two.
He was tall, with dark hair and a faint scar running along his jaw.
Unlike Noah and me, he didn't have the red birthmark above his eyebrow.
But there was something familiar about him.
The shape of his eyes.
The way he held his shoulders.
The way he looked at our father.
I knew immediately.
"Mason?""
He nodded.
"You're Ethan.""
I couldn't find the right words.
For sixteen years, I'd believed I had no siblings.
In less than twenty-four hours, I'd discovered three.
And now the oldest was standing in front of me.
Noah approached him.
"You're really our brother?""
Mason gave a small smile.
"Unless Daniel has another surprise.""
Nobody laughed.
Dad stood inside the doorway, staring at Mason as though he'd seen a ghost.
"Who told you where I lived?""
Mason looked at him.
"Your old lawyer.""
Dad's expression changed.
"Which lawyer?""
"Arthur Mitchell.""
Sarah covered her mouth.
I recognized the name.
Dad had kept business cards from Arthur in his office.
Mason pulled a folded document from his jacket.
"Mr. Mitchell contacted me two weeks ago. He said he'd been carrying something for sixteen years and couldn't live with himself anymore.""
He handed the paper to Sarah.
It was a letter.
The first sentence read:
If you're reading this, it means Daniel's arrangement has finally been exposed.
Sarah began reading aloud.
"Daniel Carter arranged for the temporary removal of four children from the family home under false medical and legal pretenses.""
She stopped.
Her hands were shaking.
Mason continued.
"The lawyer said there was a sealed court file. It contained statements from the hospital, financial records, and a report from a social worker.""
I looked at Dad.
"Why would a lawyer keep this?""
Mason answered.
"Because he knew the entire arrangement was illegal.""
Thomas stepped forward.
"Did he say anything about the hospital?""
Mason nodded.
"Yes. He said there was a nurse who refused to sign off on the twins' discharge.""
Sarah immediately looked at me.
"Margaret Ellis.""
Mason nodded.
"That's the name.""
I pulled out my phone.
"We need to find her.""
Noah was already searching.
"Wait. I found something.""
He showed us a public directory.
Margaret Ellis had retired from nursing and now lived in a small town outside Charlotte.
There was an address.
I looked at Sarah.
"Let's go.""
Dad moved toward us.
"You're not going anywhere.""
Mason turned.
"You've had sixteen years to stop us.""
For a moment, Dad looked as if he might hit him.
Then he lowered his hand.
"You're all making a mistake.""
Sarah walked toward him.
"The mistake was believing you.""
We drove to Margaret's house in two cars.
The house was small, with a white porch and a garden full of roses. A wind chime hung beside the front door.
Mason knocked.
An elderly woman answered.
She looked at us for a few seconds.
Then her eyes landed on Sarah.
"Oh, my goodness.""
Sarah stepped forward.
"Are you Margaret Ellis?""
The woman nodded.
"Yes.""
"My name is Sarah Carter. These are my children.""
Margaret looked at the four of us.
Her hand flew to her mouth.
"I wondered if this day would ever come.""
We sat in her living room.
She brought out a box of old hospital records and photographs.
"I was a nurse in the pediatric ward when the twins were admitted," she explained.
I leaned forward.
"What happened?""
Margaret folded her hands.
"Your father brought you in after claiming there had been an accident. You both had injuries. One of the doctors wanted to contact child protective services.""
Sarah closed her eyes.
Margaret continued.
"But Daniel insisted he had full custody and produced paperwork that appeared to support his claim.""
"Appeared?"" Noah asked.
"Later, we discovered some documents had been altered.""
I felt sick.
"What did you see?""
Margaret looked directly at me.
"I saw your father arguing with a woman in the hospital hallway. Vanessa.""
I glanced at Noah.
"She was there?""
Margaret nodded.
"She was carrying a folder. She told Daniel that the arrangements had already been made.""
"What arrangements?""
"She mentioned four children and four different placements.""
Sarah started crying.
Margaret reached for her hand.
"I tried to stop them from taking the twins out of the hospital. But the hospital administrator told me not to interfere because the custody documents had been approved.""
"Who approved them?"" I asked.
Margaret pulled out an old report.
At the bottom was a signature.
Arthur Mitchell.
Dad's lawyer.
Then she showed us another page.
A handwritten note from the night of the accident.
Child reports seeing father push mother during argument. Mother struck head. Vanessa present. Child repeatedly asks for sister.
My heart stopped.
"Which child said that?""
Margaret looked at me.
"You.""
I couldn't breathe.
I had spent sixteen years believing my mother had abandoned us.
But apparently, when I was two years old, I had witnessed something that no one wanted me to remember.
"Was my mother hurt?""
Margaret nodded.
"She was brought to the emergency room that night. She had a serious head injury.""
Sarah began shaking.
"I was told I was taken to a different hospital.""
Margaret looked at her.
"You were.""
I stared at her.
"Why?""
"Because Daniel told the doctors you were the one who had caused the accident.""
Sarah covered her mouth.
Noah stood up.
"That's enough. We need the full report.""
Margaret nodded and handed us a sealed envelope.
"Arthur left this with me before he retired. He told me to give it to Sarah if she ever found her children.""
Inside was a signed statement.
And a small photograph.
It showed Vanessa standing outside the hospital, holding a baby.
The baby wasn't one of us.
It was a newborn with a tiny hospital bracelet.
The name on the bracelet was clearly visible.
*MASON CARTER.*
I looked at Mason.
"Why is Vanessa holding you?""
He took the photograph.
His face went pale.
"Because she wasn't just helping my father.""
He turned it over.
Written on the back were six words.
The fourth child was never adopted.
Sarah whispered:
"Then where was he?""
Mason looked at all of us.
"That's what I've spent my entire life trying to find out.""
Then my phone rang.
It was an unfamiliar number.
A man's voice spoke.
"Ethan Carter?""
"Yes.""
"My name is Arthur Mitchell. I need you to listen carefully.""
I looked at Noah.
Arthur continued.
"Margaret gave you the wrong envelope. There is another file. And it contains the one thing Daniel has been terrified of for sixteen years.""
"What thing?""
May you like
The lawyer took a breath.
"The original recording of the night your mother disappeared.""