Amazed

Chapter 9: The Recording My Father Tried to Destroy

Arthur Mitchell agreed to meet us the following morning.

He chose a small law office near downtown Charlotte.

I barely slept that night.

Every time I closed my eyes, I saw the hospital photograph.

Vanessa holding a baby.

My father arguing with a nurse.

My mother standing in a hallway.

And a two-year-old version of me asking for a sister.

At 9:00 a.m., we entered Arthur's office.

He was a thin man in his seventies with silver glasses and a tired expression.

He stood when Sarah entered.

"Mrs. Carter.""

She didn't offer her hand.

"You helped him.""

Arthur lowered his head.

"Yes.""

"Why?""

"Because I believed the documents were legitimate. By the time I understood what Daniel had done, the damage was already enormous.""

Sarah sat down.

"Where is the recording?""

Arthur opened a locked cabinet.

He removed a small black recorder and a thick envelope.

"I kept copies because I was afraid the original evidence would disappear.""

Noah leaned forward.

"What's on it?""

Arthur placed the recorder on the desk.

"The recording was made during a meeting at the hospital. Daniel believed he was speaking privately with Vanessa. He didn't realize the device had been left running.""

He pressed play.

At first, there was static.

Then my father's voice.

"Everything needs to be finalized tonight.""

Vanessa answered.

"What about Sarah?""

"She won't remember the details.""

"Daniel, she could wake up and tell everyone what happened.""

A pause.

Then Dad said something that made Sarah grip the chair.

"That's why the report says she caused the accident.""

Vanessa lowered her voice.

"And the children?""

"The boys stay with me. Lily goes to the Morgans.""

"And Mason?""

A longer pause.

Then my father's voice became cold.

"Mason is the one we can't afford to lose control of.""

I looked at Mason.

He was staring at the recorder.

Arthur stopped the recording.

"There's more.""

He pressed play again.

Vanessa's voice came through.

"What if Sarah finds out?""

My father answered:

"She won't. She's already been declared unstable.""

"And if the children remember?""

"Then we'll make sure nobody believes them.""

The recording ended.

Nobody spoke.

Sarah was crying silently.

Noah looked like he wanted to destroy the recorder with his bare hands.

I felt something worse than anger.

I felt embarrassed.

Embarrassed that I'd defended this man.

Embarrassed that I'd repeated his lies about my mother.

Embarrassed that I'd spent sixteen years believing the woman who gave birth to me had abandoned us.

Arthur opened the envelope.

Inside were original financial records and a court order.

"The children's grandfather established separate trusts," he explained.

"Daniel had access to the accounts as temporary guardian, but he was required to use the money for the children's care.""

Noah looked at the records.

"How much was there?""

Arthur adjusted his glasses.

"Approximately $1.8 million.""

I stared at him.

"Where did it go?""

Arthur turned another page.

"Most of it was transferred into a private investment company controlled by Daniel and Vanessa.""

Mason leaned forward.

"How much remains?""

Arthur looked at him.

"Almost nothing.""

Sarah stood.

"They stole our children's future.""

Arthur nodded.

"And there's another problem.""

He handed us a separate document.

It was a guardianship agreement.

The original had been signed by Daniel.

But the copy filed with the court had a different signature.

Sarah's.

I stared at it.

"You said the documents were forged.""

Arthur nodded.

"Yes. I have proof.""

He showed us a comparison of Sarah's real signature and the forged one.

The differences were obvious.

But the next page was worse.

It contained a medical declaration stating Sarah was incapable of making decisions regarding her children.

The declaration had been signed by Dr. Evelyn Brooks.

The same woman from the photograph.

"Who was she?"" I asked.

Arthur hesitated.

"She was Vanessa's aunt.""

Sarah closed her eyes.

"Of course.""

Arthur continued.

"She was a private physician who provided Daniel with the medical paperwork he needed. She later lost her medical license after an unrelated investigation.""

Noah stood up.

"Then why hasn't Dad been arrested?""

"Because the original evidence was sealed, the witnesses disappeared, and the statute of limitations became complicated. But the financial fraud and the falsification of court documents can still be investigated.""

Mason took out his phone.

"There's something else.""

He showed us a message from an unknown number.

*You need to stop looking for the original file. You don't understand what happened to your family.*

Below it was another message.

*Ask Sarah what she did the night Mason was born.*

I looked at my mother.

"Mom?""

Sarah stared at the screen.

Her expression changed.

Arthur leaned forward.

"Mrs. Carter, is there something you haven't told us?""

Sarah began trembling.

"I remember the hospital.""

We all turned toward her.

She spoke slowly.

"Mason was born healthy. I held him for three hours. Daniel came into the room and told me he needed to take him to another department for tests.""

She wiped her cheeks.

"He never brought him back.""

Mason looked at her.

"Why didn't you report him missing?""

"I did. But Daniel showed me a document saying the baby had died during emergency treatment.""

Mason's jaw tightened.

"I was alive.""

Sarah nodded.

"I know that now.""

She reached for his hand.

"But there's something I never told anyone.""

I felt my stomach tighten.

"What?""

Sarah looked at Mason.

"Before Daniel took you away, he told me that you weren't his biological son.""

Silence.

Mason stared at her.

"What?""

Sarah began crying.

"He said he'd discovered something about your birth. He told me you belonged to another man.""

Noah shook his head.

"That's impossible. We're all siblings.""

Sarah looked toward Arthur.

The lawyer slowly opened the final page of the envelope.

It was a DNA report.

The names had been partially blacked out.

But one line remained visible.

*PATERNAL MATCH: 99.98%.*

The father's name was Daniel Carter.

Mason stared at it.

"Then why would he say that?""

Arthur turned the page.

There was another report.

This one was dated sixteen years later.

It showed a different result.

Mason's biological father was listed as someone else.

Someone whose name made Sarah collapse into her chair.

Because it was the name of the man who had supposedly died before Mason was born.

*ROBERT CARTER.*

My father's older brother.

The uncle we'd been told died in a car accident.

May you like

And Arthur had one more thing to say.

"There's a reason Daniel took all four children away. Your grandfather's will contained a clause that would have changed everything if Mason's true parentage became public.""

Related Stories

Other posts