Chapter 14: The Night on Lake Erie
I slapped Thomas.
The sound cracked through the dining room.
Nobody moved.
My palm burned.
Thomas didn't touch his face.
He simply stood there and took it.
"Six years," I whispered.
"Margaret—"
"Six years I mourned him.""
"I know.""
"Forty-eight years I was married to him.""
"I know.""
"And you let me believe I knew my husband.""
Thomas's eyes filled.
"I promised him.""
"Everyone promised Robert something except me.""
Daniel stepped forward.
"Mom.""
I turned on him.
"Don't.""
He stopped.
I hated the fear on his face.
I hated that my anger was spilling toward him.
But I had nowhere left to put it.
Officer Morales spoke carefully.
"Mr. Bennett, if you have information about Arthur Bell's disappearance, you need to tell us now.""
Thomas nodded.
"I will.""
"All of it.""
"Yes.""
He sat at my kitchen table.
The table Robert built.
The table where Daniel did homework.
The table where my husband apparently sat across from me for decades while carrying a secret about a supposedly dead man.
Thomas began.
"June 17, 1988.""
I remembered the date.
Not because of Arthur.
Because it had been the day before our anniversary.
Robert had come home after midnight.
He smelled like rain.
And gasoline.
I had asked where he'd been.
Helping Thomas with his car, he'd said.
I looked at Thomas.
"You didn't have car trouble.""
"No.""
"Where were you?""
"Lake Erie.""
My chest tightened.
"All three of you?""
"Yes.""
"Why?""
"Arthur called us.""
Thomas rubbed his hands together.
"He said he wanted to settle everything.""
"The covenant?""
"The covenant. The environmental reports. Hawthorne.""
Morales sat opposite him.
"Why meet on a boat?""
"Arthur insisted.""
"Why?""
"He said no offices. No lawyers. No records.""
"That didn't concern you?""
"It terrified me.""
"Yet you went.""
"Robert wouldn't let him go alone.""
I almost laughed.
Of course.
Robert had always mistaken loyalty for armor.
Thomas continued.
"Arthur's boat was docked outside Sandusky. We boarded around eight.""
"Was anyone else there?""
"No.""
"What happened?""
"Arthur had been drinking.""
Thomas's voice slowed.
"He accused Robert of stealing Hawthorne.""
Daniel frowned.
"How could Dad steal a company Arthur controlled?""
"Because Robert had found the covenant and recorded a protective claim tied to the central parcel.""
"My house," I said.
"Yes.""
"Without telling me.""
"Yes.""
I closed my eyes.
Thomas continued.
"Arthur said Robert had destroyed years of work. Robert said the land should never have been used as leverage because families lived there.""
"Did they fight?""
"Verbally at first.""
"At first.""
Thomas swallowed.
"Arthur pulled a gun.""
Daniel whispered, "What?""
I gripped the table.
"Did Robert have one?""
"No.""
"Did you?""
"No.""
"Then what happened?""
"Arthur pointed it at Robert.""
Thomas's eyes were no longer in my kitchen.
They were thirty-eight years away.
"He told Robert to sign over his Hawthorne interest.""
"And Robert refused.""
"Yes.""
I almost smiled.
Stubborn fool.
"Arthur hit him with the gun.""
My smile vanished.
"Where?""
"Across the face.""
I remembered.
Robert had come home with a cut near his eyebrow.
He told me he'd hit the car door.
I had held ice against it while he joked about getting old.
He had lied while I touched the evidence.
"What happened next?""
"Robert grabbed Arthur.""
Thomas stared at his hands.
"They fought.""
"The gun?""
"It fell.""
"Where?""
"On deck.""
"Did anyone pick it up?""
"I did.""
Morales leaned forward.
Thomas looked at her.
"I picked it up and threw it overboard.""
"Then?""
"Arthur punched me.""
Thomas touched his jaw as though he could still feel it.
"Robert shoved him away.""
I stopped breathing.
"Overboard?""
"No.""
"Thomas.""
"No.""
His voice broke.
"Robert did not push Arthur overboard.""
"What happened?""
"The boat hit something.""
Morales frowned.
"Something?""
"A wake. Another boat had passed nearby.""
"At night?""
"Yes.""
"Did you identify it?""
"No.""
Thomas continued.
"Arthur lost his balance. He struck the railing and went over.""
My hands tightened.
"Did you see him in the water?""
"Yes.""
"Was he conscious?""
"Yes.""
"Then you pulled him out.""
Silence.
"Thomas.""
"We tried.""
"What does that mean?""
"Robert threw a life ring.""
"And?""
"Arthur grabbed it.""
"Then what?""
Thomas's face crumpled.
"The rope snapped.""
Daniel stood.
"You're telling us he accidentally fell overboard and the rescue rope conveniently broke?""
"That's what happened.""
"Did you call the Coast Guard?""
"Immediately.""
"Then how did Arthur survive without anyone knowing?""
Thomas shook his head.
"We thought he drowned.""
"But there was blood on the deck.""
"From his head hitting the railing.""
Morales asked, "Why didn't the original investigation establish that?""
"Because we lied.""
I stared at him.
"About what?""
"The argument.""
"Why?""
"Robert panicked.""
Of all the words I had heard that night, that one felt least like my husband.
"Robert didn't panic.""
"He did that night.""
"Why?""
"Because Arthur had brought documents.""
"What documents?""
"Copies showing Robert's name on the environmental certification.""
"And?""
"Copies involving Hawthorne.""
"And?""
Thomas looked at Daniel.
"Documents involving Daniel.""
Daniel frowned.
"I was sixteen.""
"Not fraud.""
"Then what?""
Thomas hesitated.
"Arthur had been paying Daniel.""
I looked at my son.
Daniel's confusion appeared genuine.
"Paying me for what?""
"Small jobs.""
Daniel stared.
Then slowly remembered.
"The marina.""
Thomas nodded.
Daniel looked at me.
"Arthur used to give me twenty dollars to wash his car. Clean the boat.""
"I remember.""
"You thought it was pocket money.""
"It was.""
"Mostly.""
Daniel's face tightened.
"What did he have me do?""
Thomas answered.
"Deliver envelopes.""
Daniel sat.
I remembered those too.
Arthur would arrive on Saturdays.
"Hey, Danny, take this over to Mr. Walsh.""
"Hey, kid, drop this at the office.""
Ordinary errands.
At least I had thought so.
"What was in them?"" Daniel asked.
"Cash.""
Morales looked up.
"For bribes?""
Thomas nodded.
"County employees. Inspectors.""
Daniel whispered, "I was sixteen.""
"You didn't know.""
"Can you prove that?""
"Robert could.""
"How?""
"Arthur kept a ledger.""
My stomach tightened.
"The original covenant wasn't the only thing beneath the foundation.""
Thomas looked at me.
"No.""
"What else?""
"Arthur's ledger.""
Morales asked, "How did Robert get it?""
"The night Arthur disappeared.""
Thomas's voice dropped.
"After the Coast Guard arrived, Robert realized Arthur's briefcase was still on the boat.""
"What did he do?""
"He took it.""
I stared at him.
"Before police searched the boat?""
"Yes.""
"Why?""
"To protect Daniel.""
There it was again.
The phrase that had poisoned half our lives.
Daniel slammed his palm against the table.
"He should have stopped protecting me!""
Thomas stood.
"He thought Arthur was dead!""
"So?""
"He believed if police found the ledger, they'd see your name beside deliveries!""
"I was a kid!""
"Robert didn't trust them to care!""
Daniel turned away.
His shoulders shook.
I looked at Thomas.
"What did Robert do with the briefcase?""
"Brought it home.""
"That night?""
"Yes.""
My memory returned.
Robert entering after midnight.
Wet shoes.
Gasoline.
A cut above his eye.
And something else.
He had carried an old canvas tool bag.
I hadn't asked what was inside.
"What happened to the briefcase?""
"He burned it.""
"And the documents?""
"Kept some.""
"The covenant.""
"Yes.""
"The ledger.""
"Yes.""
"Environmental reports.""
"Yes.""
"And buried them.""
"Yes.""
I stood.
"Show me where.""
Morales intervened.
"Mrs. Collins, we need a proper evidence team.""
"Then bring one.""
"It's after midnight.""
"Arthur gave me until noon.""
"You're not giving Arthur anything.""
I looked at her.
"Then we need to know what he wants.""
She couldn't argue with that.
An evidence team arrived shortly after one in the morning.
Thomas led them to the basement.
Behind the storage area was a section of concrete floor that looked exactly like every other section.
Thomas pointed.
"There.""
The technician used a scanner first.
Something metallic lay beneath the slab.
They began cutting.
The sound was unbearable.
Grinding.
Breaking.
Dust filled the air.
I stood upstairs with Daniel while officers worked below.
Vanessa remained with investigators.
I hadn't seen her since they began formally questioning her.
At 2:17 a.m., Morales came upstairs.
"We found it.""
My heart hammered.
In the basement, a rusted metal case sat on a plastic evidence sheet.
Inside were old papers wrapped in waxed cloth.
A ledger.
Environmental reports.
The original covenant.
And one more envelope.
Thomas stared at it.
"I've never seen that.""
My name was written across the front.
Not Robert's handwriting.
Arthur's.
Morales opened it carefully.
Inside was a photograph.
Three men stood beside Arthur's boat.
Robert.
Thomas.
Arthur.
On the back was a date.
June 17, 1988.
The night Arthur disappeared.
But there was a fourth person in the photograph.
A woman stood partly behind Robert.
Young.
Blonde.
Smiling toward the camera.
I had never seen her before.
Daniel leaned closer.
"Who is she?""
Thomas went completely still.
"Thomas?""
He whispered a name.
"Caroline Price.""
Morales looked at him.
"Price?""
"Calvin's older sister.""
My skin prickled.
"What was she doing there?""
Thomas stared at the photograph.
"She wasn't.""
"What do you mean?""
"Caroline wasn't on the boat that night.""
"Then when was this taken?""
Thomas turned the photograph over again.
His hands shook.
"The date is wrong.""
Morales asked, "Who was Caroline Price?""
Thomas looked at me.
"Arthur's secretary.""
"And?""
He swallowed.
"Robert's girlfriend.""
The room disappeared around me.
I heard Daniel say something.
I heard Morales speak.
But all I could see was Robert's face in the photograph.
My husband.
My Robert.
Standing beside another woman.
"How long?"" I asked.
Thomas didn't answer.
I looked at him.
"How long was my husband sleeping with her?""
Thomas's eyes filled.
"He wasn't.""
I laughed bitterly.
"You just called her his girlfriend.""
"Because that's what Arthur called her.""
"What did Robert call her?""
Thomas stared at the photograph.
"His informant.""
I stopped.
"What?""
"Caroline was feeding Robert information about Arthur.""
"Then why did Arthur say they were having an affair?""
"To destroy your marriage if Robert exposed him.""
My breath came slowly.
"Did Robert ever sleep with her?""
"No.""
"Are you certain?""
"Yes.""
"How?""
Thomas looked me directly in the eyes.
"Because Caroline was in love with me.""
Silence.
Then Officer Morales's phone buzzed.
She checked it.
Her expression changed immediately.
"What?"" Daniel asked.
Morales looked at Thomas.
"We just got identification from the motel surveillance.""
My stomach tightened.
"The person who entered Richard's room after he was taken to the hospital.""
"Calvin?""
"No.""
"Arthur?""
"No.""
She turned the screen toward us.
The grainy image showed a woman wearing a hooded coat carrying a metal box from Room 214.
Her face was partially visible.
Thomas grabbed the table.
"No.""
I looked at him.
"You know her?""
His voice cracked.
"That's Caroline.""
I stared at the screen.
"Caroline Price?""
Thomas nodded.
"But she'd be...""
"Seventy-two.""
"Is she alive?""
Thomas looked at me with horror.
"She shouldn't be.""
"Why?""
May you like
His answer came slowly.
"Because Caroline Price was murdered in 1989.""