Amazed

Chapter 15: Caroline Price

"Who identified her body?""

The question came from Officer Morales.

Thomas didn't answer immediately.

He was still staring at the grainy motel image.

The woman in the hooded coat had turned toward the camera for less than a second.

Old face.

Sharp cheekbones.

Silver-blonde hair.

To me, she was a stranger.

To Thomas, apparently, she was a ghost.

"Thomas.""

Morales's voice hardened.

"Who identified Caroline Price's body in 1989?""

He finally looked away from the screen.

"Arthur.""

My stomach dropped.

"Arthur Bell?""

"Yes.""

Daniel gave a bitter laugh.

"The man who was supposedly dead?""

Thomas nodded.

"Not in person. At least, that's what we were told.""

"Explain.""

"Caroline disappeared in February 1989. Her car was found outside Toledo. Two weeks later, police recovered a woman's body near the Maumee River.""

"Cause of death?"" Morales asked.

"I don't remember.""

"You remember everything else.""

Thomas looked at her.

"Drowning, I think.""

"Think?""

"I wasn't involved in the investigation.""

"But you loved her.""

His face tightened.

"Yes.""

The word came quietly.

I looked at Thomas differently.

For all the secrets he had carried for Robert, here was one that belonged entirely to him.

"What happened after they found her?"" I asked.

"Police contacted her family. Calvin was a teenager. Their parents were already dead.""

"And Arthur?""

"According to the detective, Caroline had left documents naming Arthur as an emergency contact.""

Morales frowned.

"A legally dead man?""

"He hadn't been declared dead yet.""

Of course.

Only months had passed since the boating accident.

Arthur was missing, not legally dead.

"How did he identify her?"" Daniel asked.

"Through an attorney.""

Morales's expression sharpened.

"What attorney?""

Thomas stared at her.

Then slowly said, "Martin Vale.""

Morales wrote the name down.

"Does that mean something?"" I asked.

Thomas looked at me.

"It should.""

"Why?""

"Because Martin Vale was Hawthorne's attorney.""

The room went silent.

Daniel walked toward the basement stairs.

"So Arthur disappears. Then his secretary disappears. A body is found. Arthur's own attorney confirms it's Caroline.""

"Yes.""

"And nobody questioned that?""

"They did.""

Thomas's voice was defensive now.

"But dental records supposedly matched.""

Morales said, "Supposedly?""

Thomas looked back at the motel image.

"If that's Caroline, then they didn't.""

I thought of Richard's warning.

Don't trust Hawthorne.

Don't trust the notary.

Every institution in this story seemed to contain one person willing to turn paper into a weapon.

"Where is Martin Vale now?"" I asked.

Thomas shook his head.

"He died about ten years ago.""

Daniel laughed without humor.

"Convenient.""

"Daniel.""

"No, Mom. Everybody in this story dies exactly when they're about to explain something.""

A sound came from the basement.

An evidence technician carried another sealed plastic sleeve upstairs.

"Detective Morales?""

She stepped toward him.

"What did you find?""

"Something beneath the ledger.""

Inside the sleeve was a cassette tape.

Old.

Black plastic.

A white label had yellowed with age.

Written across it in blue ink were two words.

*CAROLINE — 1989.*

Thomas gripped the back of a chair.

"Robert had this?""

"Apparently.""

I stared at the cassette.

"Did you know?""

"No.""

For once, I believed him immediately.

Morales asked the technician, "Can we play it safely?""

"We should digitize it first.""

"How long?""

"Could be an hour.""

Thomas stepped forward.

"I need to hear it.""

"So do I," I said.

Morales looked between us.

"Then we wait.""

Waiting became unbearable.

Daniel made coffee nobody drank.

I sat in the living room and watched dawn slowly dilute the black windows into gray.

At some point, Vanessa was brought upstairs.

An officer stayed beside her.

She looked exhausted.

Daniel stood when he saw her.

Neither spoke.

Vanessa looked at me instead.

"Margaret.""

I said nothing.

"I told them everything.""

"Everything?""

Her eyes dropped.

"Everything I know.""

"Those are different things.""

She nodded.

"Yes.""

"Did you know Caroline Price?""

Vanessa looked confused.

"Calvin's sister?""

"You know the name.""

"My father mentioned her.""

Thomas stepped closer.

"What did Richard say?""

"That she betrayed Arthur.""

"How?""

"He never explained.""

"Did Calvin talk about her?""

Vanessa hesitated.

"Once.""

"What did he say?""

"That his sister died because good men were cowards.""

Thomas's face changed.

"Exact words?""

"Yes.""

"When?""

"The first night I met him.""

Thomas turned away.

Vanessa watched him.

"He hated you.""

"I gathered that.""

"He said you let her die.""

Thomas spun around.

"Where is Calvin?""

"I don't know.""

"Where would he go?""

"I don't know.""

"Think!""

The officer beside Vanessa stepped forward.

"Mr. Bennett.""

Thomas backed away.

Vanessa's voice softened.

"He has a storage unit.""

Morales immediately looked up.

"Where?""

"Near Akron.""

"Address?""

"I can give you the facility.""

"Unit number?""

"Thirty-eight.""

Morales made a call.

Daniel stared at Vanessa.

"Why didn't you tell them earlier?""

"I did.""

He looked toward Morales.

She nodded.

"Officers are already going.""

Daniel seemed almost disappointed that Vanessa had told the truth.

I understood.

When someone lies to you often enough, their honesty becomes inconvenient.

It threatens the simpler comfort of hating them completely.

The technician returned at 5:11 a.m.

"We have the recording.""

Thomas stood.

We gathered around the dining table.

Morales pressed play.

Static.

A click.

Then a woman's voice.

Young.

Nervous.

"Robert?""

My heart stopped.

Robert answered.

"Recorder's on.""

His voice.

Thirty-seven years younger.

Alive.

I closed my eyes.

For one impossible second, my husband was standing in the room again.

Caroline spoke.

"Arthur knows you kept copies.""

"I assumed.""

"He knows about the covenant.""

"Does he know where it is?""

"No.""

"Good.""

Caroline breathed shakily.

"Robert, he's alive.""

Thomas whispered, "Oh God.""

On the tape, Robert said nothing for several seconds.

Then:

"Are you sure?""

"I saw him.""

"Where?""

"Martin Vale's office.""

"When?""

"Yesterday.""

Thomas grabbed the table.

The recording continued.

"Arthur said the accident bought him time. He said everyone thinks you killed him.""

Robert's voice hardened.

"Did he threaten Margaret?""

"Not directly.""

"Caroline.""

"Yes.""

"What did he say?""

"He said wives are useful pressure points.""

My skin went cold.

Robert's chair creaked on the recording.

"I want you out.""

"I can't.""

"You can.""

"No. Calvin is still with me.""

Thomas whispered, "Her brother.""

Caroline continued.

"Arthur has been paying for Calvin's school. If I disappear, he'll know I talked.""

"Then take Calvin.""

"He's seventeen. He worships Arthur.""

Thomas closed his eyes.

Robert said, "What about the county records?""

"Vale has someone inside.""

"Name.""

"I don't know.""

"Find out.""

"I'll try.""

A pause.

Then Caroline said something that changed Thomas's face.

"Does Tommy know?""

Robert answered.

"No.""

"Don't tell him.""

"Caroline—"

"Please.""

"He's looking for you.""

"I know.""

"He thinks you're dead.""

"That's safer.""

Thomas made a broken sound.

On the recording, Caroline began crying.

"If Arthur thinks Thomas knows I'm alive, he'll use him.""

Robert's voice softened.

"Tommy loves you.""

"I know.""

"Then let him help.""

"No.""

A long silence.

Then Caroline whispered,

"Tell him I'm sorry.""

The recording clicked off.

Thomas lowered his head.

Nobody spoke.

I reached across the table.

My hand covered his.

He looked at me.

For once, neither of us needed words.

Morales's phone rang.

She answered.

"Morales.""

We watched.

Her expression sharpened.

"Secure it. Don't touch anything else.""

She ended the call.

"Storage unit?""

She nodded.

"What did they find?""

"Documents. Old photographs. Several fake identification cards.""

"And Calvin?""

"No.""

"What else?""

Morales looked at Thomas.

"A passport.""

"Whose?""

"Caroline Price.""

Thomas stood.

"Recent?""

"Issued four years ago.""

He almost collapsed.

Then Morales continued.

"There's something else.""

She looked at me.

"Officers found a wall covered in photographs.""

"Of whom?""

"You.""

My stomach tightened.

"Only me?""

"No.""

"Then who?""

"Robert. Thomas. Daniel.

Vanessa. Richard.""

Morales paused.

"And Caroline.""

Daniel whispered, "Why would Calvin watch his own sister?""

Morales's phone buzzed with an incoming image.

She opened it.

Then turned the screen toward us.

The photograph showed the wall inside the storage unit.

Dozens of faces.

Red strings.

Dates.

Addresses.

At the center was a recent photograph of Arthur Bell.

Across his face, someone had written two words in black marker.

*HE LIED.*

And beneath Arthur's photograph was a note.

*CAROLINE KNOWS WHERE THE ORIGINAL IS.*

Thomas stared at it.

"The original what?""

I looked toward the evidence boxes from beneath my basement.

The covenant.

The ledger.

The environmental reports.

Copies.

Maybe even carefully preserved copies.

But perhaps not the one thing Arthur actually needed.

Then Vanessa whispered,

"The original ownership certificate.""

We turned toward her.

"What?"" I asked.

Her face had gone pale.

"Hawthorne wasn't incorporated the way Calvin told you.""

Thomas frowned.

"What are you talking about?""

May you like

Vanessa looked at me.

"Whoever holds the original certificate controls the company.""

Related Stories

Other posts