Amazed

Chapter 2: The Woman Who Married My Husband First

I drove until my house disappeared in the rearview mirror.

I didn't know where I was going. I only knew that if Nathan came through that front door and found me sitting in the driveway, I might make the mistake of listening to him.

And I had spent seven years listening to him.

I pulled into the parking lot of a twenty-four-hour diner three miles away. The windows glowed yellow against the darkness, and the smell of fried onions drifted through the cracked window when I stopped the engine.

My hands were still shaking.

“Tell me your full name,” I said into the phone.

“Rachel Bennett.””

“Bennett?””

“Yes. I was Rachel Bennett when Nathan married me. I still am, legally.””

I stared at the steering wheel.

“Where do you live?””

“Outside Columbus, Ohio. I've lived here for the last six years.””

I tried to make the pieces fit.

Nathan had told me he grew up in Ohio but moved to Kentucky after college. He said he'd been engaged once, years ago, but the relationship had ended before the wedding.

He never mentioned a wife.

“Were you divorced?”” I asked.

“No.””

“Did you file for divorce?””

“Yes. I filed twice.””

“What happened?””

“The first time, Nathan promised he'd sign the papers. He said he needed another month to get his finances in order. Then he disappeared.

The second time, his mother called me and told me Nathan had been hospitalized after a construction accident. She begged me to withdraw the case until he recovered.””

My mouth went dry.

“Nathan was never hospitalized after a construction accident.””

“I know that now.””

I closed my eyes.

Rachel continued, her voice tight with anger.

“Diane told me he needed time. She said he was trying to save his business and that divorce would destroy him financially. I believed her because I was young, and because I loved him. I was twenty-four when we married.””

“You're telling me he kept you married to him while he married me?””

“I'm telling you that I have never received a final divorce decree. And when I checked with the court last year, the clerk confirmed that our marriage was still active.””

The diner's neon sign flickered in my windshield.

I had to remind myself to breathe.

“Then what was my wedding?””

“I don't know what Nathan told you.””

“He said the county clerk had lost our paperwork. He promised he would get a corrected certificate.””

Rachel let out a bitter laugh.

“That's what he told me when I asked why his mother was calling him a married man but refusing to tell me where he lived.””

My stomach turned.

“Why did you text him today?””

“I didn't. Someone else did.””

“Who?””

“An attorney who was helping me locate the original marriage records. She told me a new document had been requested under Nathan's name. I thought he was finally trying to correct something.””

“Correct what?””

“I don't know. That's why I messaged him.””

I looked down at the black phone.

“Rachel, I found messages between Nathan and Diane. They're talking about my inheritance.””

Silence.

Then Rachel said, “How much money?””

“Eighty-six thousand dollars. My father left it to me when he died three years ago.””

“Emily, listen carefully. You need to check whether that money is still in your account.””

My throat tightened.

“I know eighteen thousand dollars is missing.””

“Only eighteen?””

“I haven't checked the other accounts yet.””

“Then check them.””

I opened my banking app on my own phone.

The login screen appeared.

I entered my password and stared at the balance.

My savings account showed a withdrawal of $18,000.

My personal checking account was missing $4,200.

The account where I had deposited my father's inheritance showed a transfer of $12,500 to an unfamiliar business.

My chest tightened.

“No,” I whispered.

“What is it?”” Rachel asked.

“There's more money missing.””

“How much?””

“Thirty-four thousand seven hundred dollars.””

Rachel was quiet for several seconds.

Then she said, “That's almost exactly what happened to me.””

I gripped the phone harder.

“What do you mean?””

“When Nathan and I separated, I had about thirty-two thousand dollars in savings. My father had left me some money, too. Nathan told me he was investing it in equipment for his construction business. He showed me invoices, projected earnings, everything.””

“And?””

“I never saw a penny of it again.””

I looked at the black phone in my lap.

“Did you report him?””

“I tried. His mother told the police I had voluntarily given him the money. Nathan showed them a signed document saying I had authorized the transfer.””

“Did you sign it?””

“I signed a blank sheet of paper for him once. He said the accountant needed my signature for a tax form. I was twenty-five.””

My stomach twisted.

“Rachel, I think they're doing the same thing to me.””

“Then don't confront them without evidence.””

“It's a little late for that. Nathan saw me with his phone.””

“Did he threaten you?””

I looked at the windshield, remembering his finger moving across his throat.

“Yes.””

“Then go somewhere safe. A friend's house, a hotel, anywhere he can't find you easily. And do not tell Diane where you are.””

“I don't have anyone I can call at this hour.””

“Do you have a lawyer?””

“No.””

“Then call one first thing in the morning. I'll send you the name of mine.””

I glanced toward the diner's entrance. A waitress in a blue apron was wiping down a table, and a couple in their sixties were sharing a slice of pie beneath a ceiling fan.

Ordinary people.

Ordinary lives.

I suddenly felt as if I had been dropped into someone else's nightmare.

“Rachel,” I said, “why would Nathan marry me if he was still married to you?””

She took a long breath.

“Because Nathan doesn't want a wife, Emily. He wants someone who believes whatever he tells her.””

The words hurt because they sounded true.

I remembered the way Nathan controlled the household accounts. How he insisted on handling the taxes. How he said I was too busy to worry about insurance paperwork.

I remembered Diane showing up every Sunday with a list of things I needed to do differently.

I remembered Nathan telling me that a good wife trusted her husband.

Trust.

The word suddenly felt like a weapon.

“There's something else,” Rachel said.

“What?””

“Diane called me last week.””

My back straightened.

“What did she want?””

“She asked whether I still had a copy of my original marriage certificate.””

“Why?””

“She said Nathan needed it for an insurance application.””

I felt a chill crawl up my arms.

“What insurance application?””

“I don't know. I refused to send it.””

“Did she tell Nathan?””

“I assume so. Two days later, he called me for the first time in years.””

“What did he say?””

Rachel's voice dropped.

“He asked whether I'd be willing to sign a document confirming that our marriage had ended before he met you.””

I stopped moving.

“Did you?””

“No. I told him to send me a legitimate divorce decree if one existed. He hung up.””

I looked at the certificate photograph on the black phone again.

The date was eleven years ago.

Three years before Nathan and I met.

“Rachel, what happens if he tries to prove that he divorced you?””

“He would need an actual divorce record. A document doesn't become real because he says it is.””

I swallowed.

“And if he doesn't have one?””

“Then he has a serious problem.””

For the first time that night, anger pushed through the shock.

Nathan had let me build a life around a promise he knew might be false. He had taken my money, allowed his mother to humiliate me, and watched me believe I was his wife.

“What do you want from me?”” I asked.

“Nothing,” Rachel said immediately.

“I don't want your money. I don't want your house. I just want the truth on record.””

I rubbed my wet sleeves between my fingers.

“Then I'll help you.””

“Emily, don't make that promise because you're angry.””

“I'm making it because you spent eleven years believing he would do the right thing. I spent seven. Neither of us deserves another year of this.””

Rachel exhaled shakily.

“All right. I'll send you everything I have.””

A notification appeared on the phone.

It was a new message from Diane.

*Where is the phone? Nathan says you stole it. Bring it back immediately, and we can settle this quietly.*

I showed Rachel the message.

“Don't respond,” she said.

“Screenshot it.””

I did.

Another message followed.

*You have no idea what you've involved yourself in.*

I stared at the words.

Then a third message appeared.

*Your father would be ashamed of you.*

My fingers went numb.

My father had been dead for three years. Diane had attended his funeral, worn black, and hugged me in front of the church.

She had even cried.

I had thought she was grieving with me.

Now I wondered what she had been thinking as she watched me receive his inheritance.

“Rachel,” I whispered, “how did Diane know about the money my father left me?””

“Because she knew about mine,” Rachel said.

“She knew about every dollar I had.””

I looked through the diner's window at my reflection.

My hair was plastered against my cheeks. My blouse was still wet. My wedding ring glinted under the fluorescent light.

I slid it off.

For a moment, I held it in my palm.

Then I placed it in the cup holder.

“I need somewhere to sleep tonight,” I said.

“There's a motel near the interstate. I'll text you the address. Use a different payment method if you can.””

“Why?””

“Because if Nathan has access to your accounts, he may be able to track what you do with them.””

The thought made my stomach clench.

Before I could answer, another notification appeared.

This one wasn't from Diane.

It was from an unknown number.

*Emily, this is Mark Lewis. I'm Nathan's business partner. I need to talk to you before you speak to the police.*

I stared at the message.

Rachel heard my silence.

“What happened?””

I read the text aloud.

She didn't speak for several seconds.

Then she said, “Do you know Mark?””

“Only by name.””

“Then ask him one question.””

May you like

“What question?””

“Ask him whose name is on the life insurance policy Nathan took out last month.””

Related Stories

Other posts