Amazed

Chapter 5: The Document They Needed Me to Sign

Laura took the affidavit from my hand and placed it inside a clear evidence sleeve.

“Do not sign this,” she said.

“I wasn't planning to.””

“Good. And don't write on it, fold it, or send it back. We'll document how it arrived.””

Rachel stood beside the conference-room window, holding the courthouse photograph.

“That's Daniel Harris,” she said.

“I'm certain.””

Laura looked at her.

“Have you met him before?””

“No. But Nathan sent me a photograph of him years ago. He said Daniel was helping him resolve our divorce.””

She turned the picture toward us.

“He told me the paperwork was almost finished.””

I stared at the courthouse steps.

Nathan looked relaxed in the photograph. Diane stood beside him, one hand resting on his shoulder.

Daniel Harris was holding a manila folder.

The photograph had been taken seven years earlier.

The week before my wedding.

“Why would someone send this now?”” I asked.

“To intimidate you, perhaps,” Laura said.

“Or to make sure you know the document is connected to the people involved. We can't establish the sender's motive yet.””

I sat down.

The affidavit was designed to make me acknowledge something I couldn't verify. If I signed it, I might help Nathan construct a story that made his existing marriage disappear on paper.

Or I might be misunderstanding the document's legal effect.

Either way, I wasn't going to sign anything without independent advice.

“Can you contact the law firm?”” I asked.

“Yes. I'll verify the sender using independently obtained contact information rather than the details on the letter.””

Rachel placed the photograph on the table.

“I want to know why he paid Daniel Harris.””

Laura nodded.

“We'll seek records through the appropriate channels. In the meantime, we should also protect your financial accounts.””

I called my bank from the office.

After verifying my identity, I explained that I suspected unauthorized transfers and possible misuse of my personal information.

The representative placed temporary restrictions on the affected accounts and helped me open a new individual checking account.

I changed my passwords and revoked Nathan's access to the accounts I controlled.

When the representative asked whether I recognized the transfers to North Ridge Holdings, I said no.

She gave me a case number and explained that the bank's investigation team would review the transactions.

It was a small step.

But it was mine.

At four that afternoon, Laura's office received a call from the law firm named on the affidavit.

The attorney, a man named Peter Walsh, confirmed that his office had sent the document.

He said Nathan had retained them to prepare paperwork concerning his marital status.

“Did Mr. Carter tell you he was still married to Rachel Bennett?”” Laura asked.

There was a pause.

“He represented that all prior marital issues had been resolved.””

“Did he provide a final divorce decree?””

“I'll need to review the file before I can answer that.””

“Did you ask him for one?””

“I don't recall.””

Laura asked whether the firm had received any document purporting to dissolve Nathan's earlier marriage.

Peter promised to review the records and call back.

When she ended the call, Rachel let out a long breath.

“So he hired a lawyer and told them he was divorced.””

“That's what he appears to have represented,” Laura said.

“We'll need the file to know exactly what was submitted.””

I looked at the affidavit.

“Why does he need my signature?””

“Possibly to support his version of events. Possibly because he knows the records are inconsistent. We won't know until we see more.””

Rachel folded her arms.

“What if he thinks Emily will sign because she still loves him?””

I looked up.

“I don't.””

The words came out more firmly than I expected.

I had loved Nathan.

I wasn't going to pretend otherwise.

I still remembered the way he had held my hand at my father's funeral. I remembered him sleeping beside me when I had pneumonia, setting alarms to bring me medicine. I remembered dancing with him in the kitchen on our fifth anniversary.

Those memories existed.

But they no longer excused what he had done.

At six, Laura's assistant brought in another envelope.

This one was from Mark.

Inside were copies of business records, a spreadsheet of transfers, and an email chain between Nathan and Diane.

The spreadsheet showed payments from North Ridge Holdings to several accounts. Some belonged to contractors. Others had no obvious business purpose.

One transfer was labeled consulting fee.

Amount: $24,000.

Recipient: Diane Carter.

Another was labeled administrative reimbursement.

Amount: $12,500.

Recipient: North Ridge Holdings.

The date matched the transfer from my inheritance account.

I felt the blood drain from my face.

“That's my money.””

Laura leaned over the spreadsheet.

“It appears to be the same amount. We'll need the bank's records to establish the full trail.””

Rachel pointed at another entry.

“Look at this one.””

The payment was for $7,500 to Daniel Harris.

Same date as the transaction she had found.

Same recipient.

Different company account.

Laura made a note.

“This may help us trace the payment. We'll preserve the original records and request authenticated copies.””

I opened the email chain.

Nathan had written to Diane:

*Once the new paperwork is signed, Emily won't have a reason to question the accounts. We can settle the remaining balance after the transfer.*

Diane replied:

*She trusts you. That's the important part. Keep her focused on the house and the wedding certificate.*

My hands began to shake.

They had known I was asking questions.

They had known I trusted Nathan.

And they had planned around that trust.

A second email appeared below the first.

It was dated two weeks before my wedding.

*Daniel says the original can be replaced if the clerk cooperates. We need to make sure Rachel doesn't show up.*

I read it aloud.

Rachel closed her eyes.

“He told me he wanted to meet for coffee that weekend,” she whispered.

“He said he was finally ready to talk about the divorce.””

“Did you go?”” I asked.

“No. Diane called me the night before and said Nathan had changed his mind. She told me he was too upset to see me.””

Laura asked Rachel for the exact date.

Rachel checked her folder.

“October fourteenth.””

I looked at the date on my wedding invitation.

October fifteenth.

The day before my wedding, Nathan had apparently been discussing how to keep Rachel away.

I felt the room tilt.

“I stood at the altar the next day,” I said.

“He looked me in the eyes and promised to love me for the rest of his life.””

Rachel's voice was soft.

“He told me the same thing.””

For a moment, I couldn't look at her.

It was easier to imagine Nathan as a monster than to accept that the man I had loved could be both tender and cruel, affectionate and calculating.

But his messages were there.

His handwriting was there.

And the missing money was real.

At seven, Laura's phone rang.

It was the law firm.

She listened, asked several questions, and then requested copies of the complete client file.

When she hung up, she looked at us.

“Mr. Walsh says Nathan provided a document he described as a divorce decree. The firm has not yet confirmed its authenticity. He also says Nathan insisted the matter was urgent because a financial transaction depended on it.””

“What transaction?”” I asked.

“He didn't specify over the phone.””

Rachel leaned forward.

“Can he send us the document?””

“Not without reviewing his obligations to his client. But he agreed to preserve the file while we address the appropriate legal process.””

I stared at the courthouse photograph.

Something about it bothered me.

The date.

The folder.

The fact that Nathan had been standing beside Daniel Harris, apparently arranging paperwork, just before our wedding.

I pulled out my phone and zoomed in on the photograph.

There was a sign above the courthouse entrance.

The county seal.

I read the name printed beneath it.

“This isn't the courthouse where we supposedly registered our marriage.””

Laura took the photograph.

“Are you sure?””

“Yes. Our wedding took place in Franklin County. This is Hamilton County.””

Rachel studied the image.

“That's where I filed my first divorce petition.””

The room went silent.

Laura enlarged the photograph on her laptop.

A second detail appeared in the lower corner.

The manila folder bore a small label.

*Bennett v. Carter.*

Rachel stood abruptly.

“That's my case.””

I looked at her.

“Then why was Nathan standing outside that courthouse with Diane and Daniel Harris?””

Rachel's face had gone pale.

“Because that was the week I was supposed to receive my divorce papers.””

Laura immediately wrote down the date and requested that the relevant court records be preserved.

I looked at the affidavit again.

The document that needed my signature.

The insurance policy.

The money transfers.

The courthouse photograph.

Every piece seemed to point toward a plan that had begun before my wedding and continued long after it.

Then my phone rang.

Nathan.

I almost declined the call.

Instead, I pressed the speaker button and let Laura listen.

“Emily,” Nathan said, sounding strangely calm.

“I know you're with Rachel.””

I said nothing.

“Listen to me. Whatever she told you, she's leaving out the most important part.””

“Which part?””

“The part where she agreed to help me.””

Rachel froze.

Nathan continued.

“She knew I was going to marry you. She knew the paperwork was complicated. She knew everything.””

Rachel stepped closer to the phone.

“That's a lie, Nathan.””

His voice sharpened.

“Stay out of this, Rachel.””

“You told me you were getting a divorce.””

“And you told me you would wait.””

“I waited six years!””

“You don't understand what was at stake.””

I leaned toward the phone.

“What was at stake, Nathan?””

He went quiet.

Then he said, “Your father's estate.””

My heart stopped.

“What does my father have to do with this?””

“Everything.””

I gripped the edge of the table.

“My father never met you until two months before he died.””

“Exactly,” Nathan replied.

“And there's something he left behind that you haven't found.””

Laura gestured for me to keep him talking.

I swallowed.

“What did he leave behind?””

Nathan exhaled slowly.

“Your father knew about Rachel. He knew about the marriage certificate. He knew Diane had arranged the paperwork.””

My mouth went dry.

“That's impossible.””

“Ask your father's attorney,” Nathan said.

“Ask him why the inheritance was held up for six months. Ask him who requested the final accounting.””

I stared at Laura.

She was already writing down the names and questions.

Then Nathan delivered the final blow.

“Your father didn't leave you eighty-six thousand dollars, Emily.””

I stopped breathing.

“He left you a lot more than that.””

The call ended.

For several seconds, no one spoke.

Then Laura reached for the envelope containing the estate records.

“Emily,” she said carefully, “who handled your father's estate?””

I told her the attorney's name.

She searched her notes, picked up her phone, and began dialing.

Before the call connected, a message appeared on my screen.

It was from an unknown number.

*Your father left instructions to be opened only if Nathan Carter was ever investigated for fraud.*

Beneath it was an address.

May you like

And a time.

Tomorrow morning, at nine.

Related Stories

Other posts