Amazed

Chapter 9: The Letter Robert Left Behind

We returned to Ohio two days later.

My doctor had cleared me to travel with a brace and a walker, provided I stopped frequently and avoided putting Robert Left Behind

We returned to Ohio two days later.

My doctor had cleared me to travel with a brace and a walker, provided I stopped frequently and avoided putting weight on my injured leg.

Lucas insisted on driving.

Richard offered to arrange a private car, but Lucas refused.

“You've arranged weight on my injured leg.

Lucas insisted on driving.

Richard offered to arrange a private car, but Lucas refused.

“You've arranged enough things for my family,” he said.

Richard accepted the rebuke without argument.

Chloe stayed behind in Chicago with enough things for my family,” he said.

Richard accepted the rebuke without argument.

Chloe stayed behind in Chicago with her mother, although she promised she would come when Evelyn requested another interview.

I wasn't sure whether her mother, although she promised she would come when Evelyn requested another interview.

I wasn't sure whether she meant it.

The drive home took nearly seven hours because Lucas stopped whenever she meant it.

The drive home took nearly seven hours because Lucas stopped whenever my leg began to ache.

For most of the journey, we said very little.

At one rest stop, he my leg began to ache.

For most of the journey, we said very little.

At one rest stop, he bought two coffees and sat beside me on a bench outside the convenience store.

“Mom, can I ask you something?””

“Of bought two coffees and sat beside me on a bench outside the convenience store.

“Mom, can I ask you something?””

“Of course.””

“Did you ever resent Dad for keeping secrets from you?””

I looked at the paper cup in my hands.

“Sometimes course.””

“Did you ever resent Dad for keeping secrets from you?””

I looked at the paper cup in my hands.

“Sometimes.””

“Even after he died?””

“Especially after he died.””

Lucas stared across the parking lot.

“I spent my whole life believing that if I worked.””

“Even after he died?””

“Especially after he died.””

Lucas stared across the parking lot.

“I spent my whole life believing that if I worked hard enough, I could become the kind of man he was.””

“You can still be that man.””

“What if I don't know who he was?””

I reached for his hand.

hard enough, I could become the kind of man he was.””

“You can still be that man.””

“What if I don't know who he was?””

I reached for his hand.

“You know the father who taught you to ride a bicycle. The man who stayed up all night when you had pneumonia. The man“You know the father who taught you to ride a bicycle.

The man who stayed up all night when you had pneumonia. The man who cried when you graduated from high school.””

Lucas swallowed.

“Those things are real, Mom.””

“Yes.””

“Whatever we who cried when you graduated from high school.””

Lucas swallowed.

“Those things are real, Mom.””

“Yes.””

“Whatever we find, he was my father.””

I squeezed his fingers.

“Always.””

When we arrived at the house, our find, he was my father.””

I squeezed his fingers.

“Always.””

When we arrived at the house, our neighbor, Helen, was waiting on the porch.

She was seventy-four, with silver hair and a habit of neighbor, Helen, was waiting on the porch.

She was seventy-four, with silver hair and a habit of carrying peppermint candies in her coat pocket.

She hugged me carefully.

“Oh, Margaret. I wanted to call the police, but I didn't know whether carrying peppermint candies in her coat pocket.

She hugged me carefully.

“Oh, Margaret. I wanted to call the police, but I didn't know whether you wanted to wait for your son.””

“You did the right thing.””

She handed you wanted to wait for your son.””

“You did the right thing.””

She handed Lucas a key.

“The back door was unlocked when I arrived. I didn't touch anything else Lucas a key.

“The back door was unlocked when I arrived. I didn't touch anything else.””

Inside, the house looked as though someone had searched it in a hurry.

Desk drawers had been emptied. Books lay scattered across the living room floor. The.””

Inside, the house looked as though someone had searched it in a hurry.

Desk drawers had been emptied. Books lay scattered across the living room floor. The bedroom closet had been opened, and several storage boxes were overturned.

But nothing valuable appeared to be missing.

The television remained bedroom closet had been opened, and several storage boxes were overturned.

But nothing valuable appeared to be missing.

The television remained untouched.

My jewelry box sat on the dresser.

The intruder hadn't come for money.

They had come for the untouched.

My jewelry box sat on the dresser.

The intruder hadn't come for money.

They had come for the truth.

Lucas photographed every room before calling the police.

Then he helped me sit at the kitchen table.

I stared at the empty space where truth.

Lucas photographed every room before calling the police.

Then he helped me sit at the kitchen table.

I stared at the empty space where Robert's wooden box had once rested.

“I should have looked through it years ago,” I whispered.

Lucas crouched beside me.

“You Robert's wooden box had once rested.

“I should have looked through it years ago,” I whispered.

Lucas crouched beside me.

“You couldn't have known.””

“But your father left me something, and I let it sit in a box because couldn't have known.””

“But your father left me something, and I let it sit in a box because I was afraid of what it might mean.””

He looked at me.

“Then we find another way.””

I remembered something.

“Your father had a second I was afraid of what it might mean.””

He looked at me.

“Then we find another way.””

I remembered something.

“Your father had a second hiding place.””

Lucas raised his eyebrows.

“Where?””

“Behind the loose panel beneath the staircase. He used to keep emergency cash there.””

We moved carefully hiding place.””

Lucas raised his eyebrows.

“Where?””

“Behind the loose panel beneath the staircase. He used to keep emergency cash there.””

We moved carefully through the hallway.

The panel was still loose, but when Lucas removed it, we found only dust and a small brass key.

I recognized through the hallway.

The panel was still loose, but when Lucas removed it, we found only dust and a small brass key.

I recognized it immediately.

It belonged to the old filing cabinet in Robert's workshop.

We searched the cabinet until Lucas discovered it immediately.

It belonged to the old filing cabinet in Robert's workshop.

We searched the cabinet until Lucas discovered a false bottom beneath a stack of faded insurance forms.

Inside was a sealed envelope.

My name was written on a false bottom beneath a stack of faded insurance forms.

Inside was a sealed envelope.

My name was written on the front.

*Margaret. If you are reading this, the truth has finally caught up with me.*

My knees the front.

*Margaret. If you are reading this, the truth has finally caught up with me.*

My knees weakened.

Lucas guided me to a chair before I opened it.

Robert's handwriting filled four pages.

The first lines weakened.

Lucas guided me to a chair before I opened it.

Robert's handwriting filled four pages.

The first lines made my chest tighten.

*Maggie, I have spent years trying to decide whether telling you the truth would protect made my chest tighten.

Maggie, I have spent years trying to decide whether telling you the truth would protect our family or destroy it. I chose silence because I thought I could solve everything before you ever needed to know.

I our family or destroy it. I chose silence because I thought I could solve everything before you ever needed to know.*

I kept reading.

Robert explained that on the night Lucas was born, the hospital had asked him to help with an emergency transfer involving another infant kept reading.

Robert explained that on the night Lucas was born, the hospital had asked him to help with an emergency transfer involving another infant.

Richard's son had been born prematurely and required specialized care.

But there had been another baby.

.

Richard's son had been born prematurely and required specialized care.

But there had been another baby.

A second boy whose mother had died shortly after delivery.

That child's father was unknown.

Robert had helped the hospital arrangeA second boy whose mother had died shortly after delivery.

That child's father was unknown.

Robert had helped the hospital arrange transportation for both infants. During the confusion, the hospital discovered that identification bands had been removed and reattached incorrectly.

At first, everyone transportation for both infants. During the confusion, the hospital discovered that identification bands had been removed and reattached incorrectly.

At first, everyone believed it was an administrative error.

Then a nurse admitted that someone had requested access to the nursery records believed it was an administrative error.

Then a nurse admitted that someone had requested access to the nursery records before the transfer.

Robert wrote that he had seen Patricia Bennett speaking privately with a hospital administrator.

He had confronted her.

She told him that before the transfer.

Robert wrote that he had seen Patricia Bennett speaking privately with a hospital administrator.

He had confronted her.

She told him that Richard was emotionally unstable and that the company would collapse if he discovered his son had died.

She claimed she was Richard was emotionally unstable and that the company would collapse if he discovered his son had died.

She claimed she was trying to protect him.

But Robert didn't believe her.

He suspected she had removed one of the babies from the trying to protect him.

But Robert didn't believe her.

He suspected she had removed one of the babies from the hospital to prevent the authorities from discovering something about the child's identity.

The letter ended with a sentence that made my hands shake.

* hospital to prevent the authorities from discovering something about the child's identity.

The letter ended with a sentence that made my hands shake.

*Margaret, the child you brought home may not have been the child who was first placed in your arms. I have never been able to prove it. But I believe Patricia changed the records because sheMargaret, the child you brought home may not have been the child who was first placed in your arms.

I have never been able to prove it. But I believe Patricia changed the records because she knew one of those boys carried a secret that could destroy Richard's family.*

Lucas stared at the pages.

“Dad knew.””

knew one of those boys carried a secret that could destroy Richard's family.*

Lucas stared at the pages.

“Dad knew.””

I couldn't speak.

He read the final paragraph aloud.

*If anyone comes looking for these papers, do not trust Richard'sI couldn't speak.

He read the final paragraph aloud.

If anyone comes looking for these papers, do not trust Richard's wife. She has spent twenty-three years trying to protect someone, and I no longer believe that wife. She has spent twenty-three years trying to protect someone, and I no longer believe that person is Richard.

Beneath the letter lay a smaller sheet with an address in Chicago person is Richard.*

Beneath the letter lay a smaller sheet with an address in Chicago and a name.

*Eleanor Bennett's sister, Susan Hale.*

Lucas looked and a name.

*Eleanor Bennett's sister, Susan Hale.*

Lucas looked at me.

“Who is Susan Hale?””

“Richard's first wife's sister,” I whispered.

“She visited us once, at me.

“Who is Susan Hale?””

“Richard's first wife's sister,” I whispered.

“She visited us once, shortly after you were born.””

“Why would Dad write her address?””

I turned the page shortly after you were born.””

“Why would Dad write her address?””

I turned the page over.

On the back, Robert had written one final sentence.

Susan knows which baby went home with which family.

Lucas immediately called Evelyn over.

On the back, Robert had written one final sentence.

Susan knows which baby went home with which family.

Lucas immediately called Evelyn.

She listened without interrupting as he read the letter.

When he finished, she spoke carefully.

“Do.

She listened without interrupting as he read the letter.

When he finished, she spoke carefully.

“Do not contact Patricia. Do not contact Richard. I want the police to examine the break-in, and I want a certified forensic copy of that not contact Patricia.

Do not contact Richard. I want the police to examine the break-in, and I want a certified forensic copy of that letter.””

“We have a name,” Lucas said.

“Susan Hale.””

“Then I'll find her.””

Before ending the call, Evelyn added, “The DNA letter.””

“We have a name,” Lucas said.

“Susan Hale.””

“Then I'll find her.””

Before ending the call, Evelyn added, “The DNA results are expected tomorrow morning.””

Lucas looked at me.

For the first time since the wedding, I felt a fragile results are expected tomorrow morning.””

Lucas looked at me.

For the first time since the wedding, I felt a fragile thread of hope.

Perhaps the truth would finally give us something solid to hold on to.

Then Evelyn called back.

Her voice had changed.

thread of hope.

Perhaps the truth would finally give us something solid to hold on to.

Then Evelyn called back.

Her voice had changed.

“Lucas, I found Susan Hale.””

“Where is she?””

“She died six months ago.””

My“Lucas, I found Susan Hale.””

“Where is she?””

“She died six months ago.””

My hope collapsed.

Evelyn paused.

“But she left a sealed statement with her attorney. He hope collapsed.

Evelyn paused.

“But she left a sealed statement with her attorney. He says it was supposed to be opened only if someone came asking about the two boys born at St. Catherine's says it was supposed to be opened only if someone came asking about the two boys born at St. Catherine's Hospital on February 14, 2003.””

Lucas gripped the edge of the table.

“What does the statement say?””

“I don't know yet.””

Then Hospital on February 14, 2003.””

Lucas gripped the edge of the table.

“What does the statement say?””

“I don't know yet.””

Then Evelyn added the words that made the room seem suddenly cold.

May you like

“Her attorney says she specifically Evelyn added the words that made the room seem suddenly cold.

“Her attorney says she specifically instructed him to deliver it to Margaret Miller—and to no one else.””

Related Stories

Other posts