Chapter 10: The DNA Results Changed Everything

Evelyn arranged for us to meet Susan Hale's attorney the following morning.
His office occupied the top floor of an old brick for us to meet Susan Hale's attorney the following morning.
His office occupied the top floor of an old brick building in downtown Chicago, far from the glass towers where Richard Bennett conducted business.
The attorney, Martin building in downtown Chicago, far from the glass towers where Richard Bennett conducted business.
The attorney, Martin Cole, was in his late seventies. He wore suspenders, carried a fountain pen, and looked at me with an expression that was almost sorrowful.
“Mrs. Miller,” he said, “ Cole, was in his late seventies. He wore suspenders, carried a fountain pen, and looked at me with an expression that was almost sorrowful.
“Mrs. Miller,” he said, “I've been waiting a long time for this meeting.””
I sat beside Lucas.
“Did you know my husband?””
“Only through Susan. She toldI've been waiting a long time for this meeting.””
I sat beside Lucas.
“Did you know my husband?””
“Only through Susan. She told me about Robert's efforts to discover what happened at St. Catherine's.””
“Why didn't she contact me me about Robert's efforts to discover what happened at St. Catherine's.””
“Why didn't she contact me?””
Martin lowered his eyes.
“She was afraid.””
“Of Patricia?””
“Of what Patricia might do if she learned Susan had kept evidence.””
He unlocked?””
Martin lowered his eyes.
“She was afraid.””
“Of Patricia?””
“Of what Patricia might do if she learned Susan had kept evidence.””
He unlocked a filing cabinet and removed a thick manila envelope.
“Your husband's letter was not the only document Susan preserved.””
He laid a filing cabinet and removed a thick manila envelope.
“Your husband's letter was not the only document Susan preserved.””
He laid three items on the desk.
The first was a hospital photograph showing two newborn boys in separate bassinets.
The second was a typed statement signed by a nurse.
The third was a sealed three items on the desk.
The first was a hospital photograph showing two newborn boys in separate bassinets.
The second was a typed statement signed by a nurse.
The third was a sealed DNA report dated twenty-two years earlier.
Lucas leaned forward.
“Someone tested the babies back then?””
Martin nodded.
“Susan told DNA report dated twenty-two years earlier.
Lucas leaned forward.
“Someone tested the babies back then?””
Martin nodded.
“Susan told me that a private test was arranged after the hospital investigation stalled. She never explained who paid for it.””
I stared at the report.
me that a private test was arranged after the hospital investigation stalled. She never explained who paid for it.””
I stared at the report.
“Why wasn't it given to the families?””
“According to Susan, Patricia intercepted the results.””
Lucas's face hardened.
““Why wasn't it given to the families?””
“According to Susan, Patricia intercepted the results.””
Lucas's face hardened.
“Then she knew.””
Martin didn't answer.
He slid the report toward me.
My fingers trembled as I opened it.
The documentThen she knew.””
Martin didn't answer.
He slid the report toward me.
My fingers trembled as I opened it.
The document identified two infants by temporary hospital numbers. One was linked to Richard Bennett. identified two infants by temporary hospital numbers.
One was linked to Richard Bennett. The other was linked to a couple identified as Robert and Margaret Miller.
But the conclusion was not what I expected.
The test had The other was linked to a couple identified as Robert and Margaret Miller.
But the conclusion was not what I expected.
The test had confirmed that Richard Bennett was the biological father of one infant.
It had also confirmed that Robert Miller was the biological father of the other.
Lucas ex confirmed that Richard Bennett was the biological father of one infant.
It had also confirmed that Robert Miller was the biological father of the other.
Lucas exhaled sharply.
“So the babies weren't switched.””
Martin adjusted his glasses.
“Not according to this report.””
I felt myhaled sharply.
“So the babies weren't switched.””
Martin adjusted his glasses.
“Not according to this report.””
I felt my entire body go weak with relief.
Lucas was Robert's biological son.
The man who had raised him was also entire body go weak with relief.
Lucas was Robert's biological son.
The man who had raised him was also the man whose blood he carried.
For a moment, I could only cry.
Lucas knelt beside my the man whose blood he carried.
For a moment, I could only cry.
Lucas knelt beside my chair.
“Mom?””
I held his face between my hands.
“Your father was your father in every way that mattered.””
He leaned chair.
“Mom?””
I held his face between my hands.
“Your father was your father in every way that mattered.””
He leaned forward and pressed his forehead against mine.
“I know.””
But our relief lasted only seconds.
Lucas looked at the report again.
“Then why did Patricia alter the records?””
Martin forward and pressed his forehead against mine.
“I know.””
But our relief lasted only seconds.
Lucas looked at the report again.
“Then why did Patricia alter the records?””
Martin removed the nurse's statement.
“Because the test established something else.””
He handed it to Evelyn.
She removed the nurse's statement.
“Because the test established something else.””
He handed it to Evelyn.
She read the document, her expression growing more serious with every line.
“What is it?”” Lucas asked.
Evelyn looked read the document, her expression growing more serious with every line.
“What is it?”” Lucas asked.
Evelyn looked at me.
“The nurse states that the child identified as Richard Bennett's biological son was removed from the hospital by Patricia Bennett before the final medical clearance.””
at me.
“The nurse states that the child identified as Richard Bennett's biological son was removed from the hospital by Patricia Bennett before the final medical clearance.””
Richard's son.
The boy who might have been Chloe's brother.
Lucas stood.
“Where didRichard's son.
The boy who might have been Chloe's brother.
Lucas stood.
“Where did she take him?””
Martin opened the envelope again.
“That's the question Susan spent years trying to answer.””
He produced another document.
It was a bank she take him?””
Martin opened the envelope again.
“That's the question Susan spent years trying to answer.””
He produced another document.
It was a bank transfer record showing a substantial payment to a private medical facility in Indiana.
The recipient was a trust registered under the name of transfer record showing a substantial payment to a private medical facility in Indiana.
The recipient was a trust registered under the name of Patricia's maiden name.
Evelyn studied the paperwork.
“This looks like a payment for long-term care.””
“ Patricia's maiden name.
Evelyn studied the paperwork.
“This looks like a payment for long-term care.””
“That's what Susan believed,” Martin replied.
“She thought Patricia placed the child in a private facility and then used her influence to conceal his identity.””
Lucas staredThat's what Susan believed,” Martin replied.
“She thought Patricia placed the child in a private facility and then used her influence to conceal his identity.””
Lucas stared at the document.
“Why would she do that?””
Martin hesitated.
“Because the boy had a medical condition that at the document.
“Why would she do that?””
Martin hesitated.
“Because the boy had a medical condition that Patricia believed would threaten the Bennett family's reputation.””
I felt sick.
“She hid a child because she was ashamed of him?””
“Poss Patricia believed would threaten the Bennett family's reputation.””
I felt sick.
“She hid a child because she was ashamed of him?””
“Possibly,” Martin said.
“But Susan believed there was another reason.””
He placed one final letter on the desk.
It was addressed to Richardibly,” Martin said.
“But Susan believed there was another reason.””
He placed one final letter on the desk.
It was addressed to Richard.
The letter had never been mailed.
Martin explained that Susan had found it among her.
The letter had never been mailed.
Martin explained that Susan had found it among her sister's belongings after Eleanor's death. She had kept it because she believed it might one day help identify the missing child.
Lucas sister's belongings after Eleanor's death. She had kept it because she believed it might one day help identify the missing child.
Lucas read the first lines aloud.
*Richard, if anything happens to me, you must find our son. Patricia says he read the first lines aloud.
Richard, if anything happens to me, you must find our son. Patricia says he is being cared for, but I have seen the records. She has changed his name, his medical history, and the identity of the person responsible for him.
is being cared for, but I have seen the records. She has changed his name, his medical history, and the identity of the person responsible for him.*
Richard had not been present, but I could imagine his face if he heard those words.
Lucas continuedRichard had not been present, but I could imagine his face if he heard those words.
Lucas continued.
She tells me she is protecting our family. I believe she is protecting herself.
The letter ended abruptly.
There was no signature.
Only one additional sentence, written in a different hand.
**.
She tells me she is protecting our family. I believe she is protecting herself.
The letter ended abruptly.
There was no signature.
Only one additional sentence, written in a different hand.
*The child is alive. His new name is recorded in the private facility's admissionThe child is alive. His new name is recorded in the private facility's admission book.*
Evelyn photographed every page.
“We'll have to verify the facility, locate the admission records, and determine whether the child is still alive.””
book.**
Evelyn photographed every page.
“We'll have to verify the facility, locate the admission records, and determine whether the child is still alive.””
Lucas looked at the bank transfer.
“Can we find the facility?””
Martin pointed to the address.
“It's still operating, although it has changed ownership twiceLucas looked at the bank transfer.
“Can we find the facility?””
Martin pointed to the address.
“It's still operating, although it has changed ownership twice.””
Evelyn immediately began making calls.
While she worked, Lucas stepped into the hallway to contact Richard.
I heard only his side of the conversation.
“Dad, the.””
Evelyn immediately began making calls.
While she worked, Lucas stepped into the hallway to contact Richard.
I heard only his side of the conversation.
“Dad, the old DNA report confirms I'm Robert Miller's biological son.””
A pause.
“No, that doesn't mean this is over.””
Another pause.
“Because Patricia may have old DNA report confirms I'm Robert Miller's biological son.””
A pause.
“No, that doesn't mean this is over.””
Another pause.
“Because Patricia may have hidden your son.””
Silence.
Then Lucas said, “You need to come to Chicago. And hidden your son.””
Silence.
Then Lucas said, “You need to come to Chicago. And you need to bring Chloe.””
He ended the call and returned to the office.
“Richard is coming.””
I looked at the you need to bring Chloe.””
He ended the call and returned to the office.
“Richard is coming.””
I looked at the documents.
For twenty-three years, I had believed that the worst thing Richard Bennett had done was refuse to repay the money he owed us.
I had been wrong.
He had lost a documents.
For twenty-three years, I had believed that the worst thing Richard Bennett had done was refuse to repay the money he owed us.
I had been wrong.
He had lost a child without ever knowing where that child went. My husband had spent years searching for answers child without ever knowing where that child went. My husband had spent years searching for answers. Patricia had apparently built a wall of lies around a boy who might still be alive.
And now. Patricia had apparently built a wall of lies around a boy who might still be alive.
And now, at last, we had a name.
Evelyn found it in the admission book within an hour.
The boy had been registered, at last, we had a name.
Evelyn found it in the admission book within an hour.
The boy had been registered at the Indiana facility under the name *Daniel Price*.
His date of birth matched Richard's son's at the Indiana facility under the name *Daniel Price*.
His date of birth matched Richard's son's.
But the most recent record was dated only three weeks earlier.
Lucas leaned over her shoulder.
“What does it.
But the most recent record was dated only three weeks earlier.
Lucas leaned over her shoulder.
“What does it say?””
Evelyn read the entry twice.
Then she looked up.
“Daniel Price was discharged from the facility twenty-three days say?””
Evelyn read the entry twice.
Then she looked up.
“Daniel Price was discharged from the facility twenty-three days ago.””
“Where did he go?””
She turned the page.
A signature appeared beneath the discharge authorization.
*Patricia Bennett.*
And ago.””
“Where did he go?””
She turned the page.
A signature appeared beneath the discharge authorization.
*Patricia Bennett.*
And beside it was a destination address.
Richard's home.
I stared at the page, unable beside it was a destination address.
Richard's home.
I stared at the page, unable to breathe.
Because Patricia hadn't merely hidden the child.
She had brought him back.
And if Daniel Price was living to breathe.
Because Patricia hadn't merely hidden the child.
She had brought him back.
And if Daniel Price was living under Richard's roof, then someone in that family had known the truth for years.
Someone had known where Richard under Richard's roof, then someone in that family had known the truth for years.
Someone had known where Richard's missing son was.
And someone had allowed Richard to believe he was gone.
May you like
's missing son was.
And someone had allowed Richard to believe he was gone.
Related Stories