Chapter 2: The Footage He Thought Would Disappear

Within fifteen minutes, the courthouse hallway had become a crime scene.
Two sheriff's deputies arrived. One escorted Officer Collins away from the crowd while the other asked witnesses to remain available for statements.
I sat in a small conference room with an ice pack pressed against my cheek.
My lip had stopped bleeding, but the swelling was already spreading toward my jaw.
Thomas stood near the door.
He hadn't said much since the incident.
Finally, he spoke.
"Judge, I've worked with that officer for almost four years.""
I looked up.
"And?""
He hesitated.
"I've seen him lose his temper before.""
"How often?""
Thomas rubbed his forehead.
"More than once.""
"Have you reported it?""
His silence answered before he did.
"Once. Maybe twice.""
"Maybe?""
"I filed a written complaint last year. Another deputy witnessed him shove a man against a wall after the man had already been restrained.""
I put the ice pack down.
"What happened to the complaint?""
Thomas looked toward the hallway.
"It disappeared.""
I stared at him.
"Complaints don't disappear, Thomas.""
He gave me a tired look.
"On paper, they don't.""
Before I could ask another question, District Attorney Robert Hayes entered.
He closed the door behind him.
"Administrative Judge Franklin is on his way. The sheriff has ordered Collins removed from public duty pending an initial review.""
"Good.""
Robert pulled a chair closer.
"But there's another problem.""
I waited.
"The case you were scheduled to hear this morning.""
I remembered immediately.
People v. Marcus Hill.
A twenty-six-year-old delivery driver accused of assaulting a police officer during a traffic stop.
The arresting officer was Derek Collins.
Robert placed a folder on the table.
"Collins is the primary witness.""
I looked at the folder.
"Was he scheduled to testify today?""
"Yes.""
"Then why wasn't I informed that he was assigned to courthouse security?""
Robert rubbed his chin.
"I don't know. His assignment was approved by the sheriff's department.""
I opened the folder.
The case summary contained three photographs of Marcus Hill's injuries.
A bruised eye.
A swollen wrist.
A deep cut above his eyebrow.
According to the police report, Marcus had violently resisted arrest and injured Collins during the encounter.
But the photographs told a different story.
"Who examined the body-camera footage?"" I asked.
"The prosecution received it last week.""
"And?""
Robert looked uncomfortable.
"There are several minutes missing.""
I slowly raised my eyes.
"Missing?""
"That's what the defense claims. The recording begins after the physical confrontation.""
"Was the original file preserved?""
"We requested it.""
"And?""
"They haven't provided it.""
I leaned back.
For six years, I had handled cases involving everything from petty theft to organized financial fraud. I knew the difference between an administrative error and a suspicious pattern.
A police officer who struck a woman in a courthouse hallway was one problem.
A police officer whose testimony might determine whether an innocent man went to prison was another.
"Robert, I want this case reviewed by another judge.""
He nodded.
"That's probably wise.""
"Not probably. It is.""
He stood.
"I'll speak with Judge Franklin.""
When he left, my phone buzzed.
An unfamiliar number.
I almost ignored it, but the message caught my attention.
*Judge Bennett, my brother Marcus is in jail because of Officer Collins. I heard what happened this morning. Please don't let them bury this again.*
I stared at the screen.
A second message arrived.
*My name is Danielle Hill. I've been trying to get someone to listen for eight months.*
I called the number.
A woman answered almost immediately.
"Hello?""
"This is Judge Maya Bennett.""
There was a sharp intake of breath.
"Your Honor?""
"How did you get my number?""
"Mr. Reed gave it to me. He said you might finally listen.""
I glanced toward the closed door.
"What happened to your brother?""
She began crying.
"They said he attacked the officer. They said he was dangerous. But my brother was driving home from work.
He had a broken taillight. That's all.""
"Do you have evidence?""
"I have something. I found a video on his phone that the police never mentioned.""
My fingers tightened around the phone.
"What kind of video?""
"The traffic stop. The entire thing.""
I sat forward.
"Have you provided it to the defense?""
"Three times.""
"And?""
"They told me they never received it.""
A cold feeling settled in my stomach.
"Do you still have the original?""
"Yes. It's on my brother's old phone.""
"Don't send it to anyone yet. Preserve the device and make a copy without altering the original.""
She sniffled.
"Does this mean you'll help him?""
I looked at the courthouse clock.
"I cannot personally preside over a matter involving evidence that may implicate someone who assaulted me this morning. But I can make sure the proper authorities receive your information.""
"Thank you.""
She hesitated.
"Your Honor?""
"Yes?""
"There's something else.""
"What?""
"My brother told me Officer Collins wasn't alone that night.""
I stopped breathing for a moment.
"Who was with him?""
Danielle whispered a name.
"Sergeant William Price.""
I knew that name.
Price was the supervisor responsible for courthouse security assignments.
He was also the officer who had approved Collins's placement in the public lobby that morning.
I ended the call and immediately contacted Judge Franklin.
When he arrived, I explained everything.
He listened without interrupting.
Then he asked the question I had been dreading.
"Maya, do you believe the assault this morning was intentional?""
I looked at the photograph of Marcus Hill.
"I believe we need to investigate whether I was targeted.""
Franklin frowned.
"Targeted?""
"Collins knew my schedule. He knew I was assigned to Courtroom 4B. And he was standing in the exact hallway I needed to use.""
"Are you suggesting someone arranged this?""
"I'm suggesting we shouldn't assume it was coincidence.""
He studied me for several seconds.
Then he closed the folder.
"I'll appoint another judge to the Hill case. You'll have no involvement in its rulings.""
"Agreed.""
He stood.
"But I want you to understand something. If this reaches the press, the courthouse will be under enormous scrutiny.""
I looked at my reflection in the dark conference room window.
One side of my face was swollen.
A thin red line crossed my lower lip.
"Judge Franklin, the courthouse should be under scrutiny.""
He said nothing.
Then his phone rang.
He answered, listened, and slowly looked at me.
When he hung up, his expression had changed.
"That was the sheriff.""
"What happened?""
He lowered his voice.
"Officer Collins has made a statement.""
"What did he say?""
May you like
Franklin hesitated.
"He claims you attacked him first.""