Amazed

Chapter 3: The Report That Changed Everything

By noon, the first version of the incident report had been submitted.

According to Officer Derek Collins, I had approached him in an aggressive manner, refused lawful instructions, attempted to reach into my purse, and physically resisted detention.

He claimed that the contact with my face occurred while he was trying to protect himself.

There was only one problem.

Nearly thirty people had witnessed the incident.

And at least seven had recorded it.

Still, I knew better than to assume the truth would automatically win.

I was sitting in my chambers when Thomas knocked.

He entered carrying two cups of coffee.

"Black, no sugar," he said, placing one beside me.

"Thank you.""

He looked at my face.

"That swelling looks worse.""

"I've had better mornings.""

He pulled a chair forward.

"Judge, there's something you need to know about Collins.""

I set down my pen.

"Go ahead.""

"Three months ago, he was involved in another incident in the lobby.""

"What happened?""

"A woman came in to testify against her former boyfriend. Collins accused her of being intoxicated because she was crying.""

"Was she arrested?""

"No. But he grabbed her arm and threatened to have her removed.""

"Did she file a complaint?""

"Yes.""

"Where is it?""

Thomas lowered his voice.

"That's what I'm trying to tell you. Her complaint was dismissed because the security footage supposedly malfunctioned.""

I looked at him.

"Again?""

He nodded.

I opened my laptop.

"Do you remember her name?""

"Angela Morris.""

I typed it into the courthouse records system.

Nothing.

I tried again using the date Thomas provided.

A record appeared.

Then disappeared.

I frowned.

"That's strange.""

Thomas leaned closer.

"What?""

"The system shows a complaint was filed, but the document itself is inaccessible.""

I clicked the entry.

A message appeared.

*RECORD RESTRICTED — ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW REQUIRED.*

I turned toward Thomas.

"Who restricted it?""

He looked away.

"Sergeant Price.""

The room became very quiet.

I printed the screen and placed it in a folder.

"Thomas, I need you to understand that from this moment forward, you must not access any records you're not authorized to see. Don't speak to witnesses about what they should say. Don't contact Collins.""

"I understand.""

"And if anyone asks you to alter, delete, or withhold anything, report it immediately.""

Thomas nodded.

Then he surprised me.

"Judge, I should have done something sooner.""

I looked at him.

"About Collins?""

"About all of it.""

His eyes were wet.

"I watched people get pushed around because they didn't have money or influence. I told myself it wasn't my job. I told myself someone higher up would handle it.""

He looked at the photograph of my injured face.

"Today, he did it to you.""

I stood and walked toward the window.

"Thomas, the problem isn't that he chose the wrong person to hit.""

He frowned.

"The problem is that he thought he could hit anyone.""

Before he could respond, my assistant, Laura Mitchell, entered without knocking.

"Judge Bennett, the press is downstairs.""

I turned.

"How many?""

"Several television crews. Someone posted the hallway video online.""

She held up her phone.

The video was already circulating.

The footage showed Collins blocking my path, grabbing my arm, and striking me.

The sound was unmistakable.

So was his expression afterward.

The video had been viewed more than half a million times.

Comments were pouring in.

Some demanded his arrest.

Others accused the courthouse of protecting its own.

One comment caught my attention.

*That's Officer Collins. He did the same thing to my father last summer. The department told us there was no evidence.*

Another read:

*My cousin filed a complaint against Sergeant Price. It vanished too.*

I handed the phone back.

"Laura, don't respond to anything.""

"I wasn't planning to.""

"Contact the county inspector general. Tell them I want an independent preservation order covering every relevant security recording, personnel record, complaint, and communication.""

Laura nodded.

Then she hesitated.

"There's something else.""

"What?""

"The sheriff's office called. They want you to attend a meeting at two.""

"Who requested it?""

"Sergeant Price.""

I slowly closed the folder.

"Decline.""

"That's what I thought.""

"No, Laura. Don't just decline. Tell them any discussion concerning this incident must take place through the independent investigators.""

She nodded and left.

At 1:17 p.m., my phone rang.

Unknown number.

I answered.

"Judge Bennett.""

A man's voice came through.

"Your Honor, this is Sergeant William Price.""

I leaned back.

"Sergeant.""

"I wanted to personally apologize for what happened this morning.""

"That is a matter for the investigation.""

"Of course. But I think we should clear up some misunderstandings before things get out of hand.""

"What misunderstandings?""

He sighed.

"Officer Collins is a good man. He's under tremendous pressure. Sometimes people in law enforcement have to make difficult split-second decisions.""

I looked at the incident report.

"He had time to listen when I told him my name.""

"Perhaps he didn't recognize you.""

"He didn't need to recognize me to understand that striking a restrained woman was unacceptable.""

There was a pause.

Then Price's voice became colder.

"Judge, with respect, you don't understand how complicated these situations can be.""

I almost laughed.

"I have spent sixteen years studying the law and six years applying it from the bench.""

"That's not what I meant.""

"Then explain what you meant.""

Silence.

Finally, he said, "You might want to consider how much damage this could cause to the courthouse.""

I looked at the phone.

"Sergeant Price, are you warning me?""

"I'm trying to help you.""

"No. You're trying to make me responsible for the consequences of someone else's conduct.""

He exhaled sharply.

"Be careful, Your Honor.""

The call ended.

I stared at the screen.

Then I opened the incident report again.

There was a section near the bottom labeled:

*SUPERVISORY REVIEW.*

The report had been approved at 10:42 a.m.

Only twenty minutes after the assault.

The reviewing supervisor's name was William Price.

And underneath his electronic signature was a statement that made my stomach turn.

*Subject appeared to be an intoxicated female defendant. Physical intervention was necessary.*

I read it twice.

I hadn't been intoxicated.

I hadn't been a defendant.

And Collins hadn't written the report alone.

Someone had already helped him construct a version of events.

My computer chimed.

An email had arrived from the county inspector general.

The subject line read:

*URGENT — PRESERVATION REQUEST RECEIVED.*

I opened it.

There was one attachment.

A photograph of a printed internal message.

The message was dated the previous evening.

And the sender was Sergeant William Price.

Its contents were brief.

*Make sure Collins is assigned to the east lobby tomorrow morning. Bennett will be coming through the public entrance. Keep the situation controlled.*

I stared at the screen.

May you like

Then I read the final sentence.

*We cannot afford another Hill hearing.*

Related Stories

Other posts